Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

Vulken because if I had them as brothers with the exception of maybe sanguinis (because everyone loves him for good reason) id hate them all.

But he doesn't it during the crusade he seems to try and like them all even the ones like ferrus and dorn who were hard to get along with.

gilamonster wrote:
Vulken because if I had them as brothers with the exception of maybe sanguinis (because everyone loves him for good reason) id hate them all.

But he doesn't it during the crusade he seems to try and like them all even the ones like ferrus and dorn who were hard to get along with.

Puts on SS Grammar Hat

Vulkan because he is the most brotherly except for Sangunius. (Everyone Loves Sanguinius). Basically I hate all of them.

But during the crusade he is not very brotherly. I like them all, Ferrus and dorn, yet those two had a hard time getting along.

Lulz wut?

Why is there no Omegon? I'm sure there are some Omegon fans out there.

Technically after the Heresy, but I find it hilarious no one believes Guilliman slayed Alpharius. That and the fact that Fulgrim poisoned him.

 jreilly89 wrote:
Technically after the Heresy, but I find it hilarious no one believes Guilliman slayed Alpharius. That and the fact that Fulgrim poisoned him.

Well, I think most of us do, but there are two primarchs to the Alpha Legion. Ergo, theres still one of them, be it Alpharius or Omegon (Oh who even knows whos who anymore) floating around.

On a separate note, frankly, Im a little dissapointed Dakka. Fulgrim at 3 percent? 3 percent?

 Jollydevil wrote:

 jreilly89 wrote:
Technically after the Heresy, but I find it hilarious no one believes Guilliman slayed Alpharius. That and the fact that Fulgrim poisoned him.

Well, I think most of us do, but there are two primarchs to the Alpha Legion. Ergo, theres still one of them, be it Alpharius or Omegon (Oh who even knows whos who anymore) floating around.

On a separate note, frankly, Im a little dissapointed Dakka. Fulgrim at 3 percent? 3 percent?

Fulgrim is a terrible Primarch, just an awful character really. 3% is far too high

Yeah honestly the only cool thing fulcrum did was choke out the avatar

 ImAGeek wrote:

 Jollydevil wrote:

 jreilly89 wrote:
Technically after the Heresy, but I find it hilarious no one believes Guilliman slayed Alpharius. That and the fact that Fulgrim poisoned him.

Well, I think most of us do, but there are two primarchs to the Alpha Legion. Ergo, theres still one of them, be it Alpharius or Omegon (Oh who even knows whos who anymore) floating around.

On a separate note, frankly, Im a little dissapointed Dakka. Fulgrim at 3 percent? 3 percent?

Fulgrim is a terrible Primarch, just an awful character really. 3% is far too high

Fulgrim before the Heresy Series was cool imo, what little fluff we had on him at least, and he was my favourite Primarch. Now, ugh ...

SirSertile wrote:
Why is there no Omegon? I'm sure there are some Omegon fans out there.

Wouldn't that just split the Alpharius votes? And they are all Alpharius. Or they are all Omegon.

And I see the Lion is making a comeback. Just as planned...

ImAGeek wrote:

 Jollydevil wrote:

 jreilly89 wrote:
Technically after the Heresy, but I find it hilarious no one believes Guilliman slayed Alpharius. That and the fact that Fulgrim poisoned him.

Well, I think most of us do, but there are two primarchs to the Alpha Legion. Ergo, theres still one of them, be it Alpharius or Omegon (Oh who even knows whos who anymore) floating around.

On a separate note, frankly, Im a little dissapointed Dakka. Fulgrim at 3 percent? 3 percent?

Fulgrim is a terrible Primarch, just an awful character really. 3% is far too high

theemporerprotectsnone wrote:Yeah honestly the only cool thing fulcrum did was choke out the avatar

Pilau Rice wrote:

 ImAGeek wrote:

 Jollydevil wrote:

 jreilly89 wrote:
Technically after the Heresy, but I find it hilarious no one believes Guilliman slayed Alpharius. That and the fact that Fulgrim poisoned him.

Well, I think most of us do, but there are two primarchs to the Alpha Legion. Ergo, theres still one of them, be it Alpharius or Omegon (Oh who even knows whos who anymore) floating around.

On a separate note, frankly, Im a little dissapointed Dakka. Fulgrim at 3 percent? 3 percent?

Fulgrim is a terrible Primarch, just an awful character really. 3% is far too high

Fulgrim before the Heresy Series was cool imo, what little fluff we had on him at least, and he was my favourite Primarch. Now, ugh ...

IMHO I thought Fulgrim was fleshed out really well in the book. Hes essentially an egocentric maniac defiled by slaanesh. I especially liked how well you could see him slowly becoming insane, to the climax of the chaos at La Fenice.
Sure, hes a bit of a jerk, but it certainly gives him charachter, at least more so than the "Watch me be almighty" Rogal Dorn (and many of the other primarchs who I think act the same way).
But thats just my opinion, and why Fulgrim is definitely my favorite of the list.

I think Fulgrim was actually written quite well. I actually started to hate him!

Why Is that selfish bastard the lion so high? Sanguinius is undisputedly the best Primarchs. He's a beast in CC, he's a badass angel with wings, he's an untrained Psyker, he's the first Imperial Farseer, what's not to love?

 dusara217 wrote:
Why Is that selfish bastard the lion so high? Sanguinius is undisputedly the best Primarchs. He's a beast in CC, he's a badass angel with wings, he's an untrained Psyker, he's the first Imperial Farseer, what's not to love?

'cause he's the third best Primarch. The top three of awesome Primarchs is clearly
1) Perturabo
2) Ferrus Manus
3) The Lion

 Jollydevil wrote:

IMHO I thought Fulgrim was fleshed out really well in the book. Hes essentially an egocentric maniac defiled by slaanesh. I especially liked how well you could see him slowly becoming insane, to the climax of the chaos at La Fenice.
Sure, hes a bit of a jerk, but it certainly gives him charachter, at least more so than the "Watch me be almighty" Rogal Dorn (and many of the other primarchs who I think act the same way).
But thats just my opinion, and why Fulgrim is definitely my favorite of the list.

See, I was never a fan of Rogal Dorn, but the Heresy has made the Stone Man my favourite.

I get what you are saying about Fulgrim, he is written well, I just think they took him down the wrong path. I think if they had made him less of a cock it would have been better and his fall that more tragic. What with the possession story as well, which I think wasn't needed.

 Jollydevil wrote:
dfb1d645a5dcb80a5756c7.png]
IMHO I thought Fulgrim was fleshed out really well in the book. Hes essentially an egocentric maniac defiled by slaanesh. I especially liked how well you could see him slowly becoming insane, to the climax of the chaos at La Fenice.
Sure, hes a bit of a jerk, but it certainly gives him charachter, at least more so than the "Watch me be almighty" Rogal Dorn (and many of the other primarchs who I think act the same way).
But thats just my opinion, and why Fulgrim is definitely my favorite of the list.

I think it would have been much much better if he wasn't so much of an arse to start with. His fall would've had more weight to it then but the way it's written it just seems so obvious, he basically starts half way there.

 Pilau Rice wrote:

 Jollydevil wrote:

IMHO I thought Fulgrim was fleshed out really well in the book. Hes essentially an egocentric maniac defiled by slaanesh. I especially liked how well you could see him slowly becoming insane, to the climax of the chaos at La Fenice.
Sure, hes a bit of a jerk, but it certainly gives him charachter, at least more so than the "Watch me be almighty" Rogal Dorn (and many of the other primarchs who I think act the same way).
But thats just my opinion, and why Fulgrim is definitely my favorite of the list.

See, I was never a fan of Rogal Dorn, but the Heresy has made the Stone Man my favourite.

I get what you are saying about Fulgrim, he is written well, I just think they took him down the right path. I think if they had made him less of a cock it would have been better and his fall that more tragic. What with the possession story as well, which I think wasn't needed.

Overall Fulgrim was a good leader. He was plenty inspiring, led by example, etc etc. I respect the fact that he didnt just care about war either, but was a huge patron of the arts.
Personally, I like the fact that chaos was able to grab hold of the thin string of flaw he had (arrogance, pride, etc), and basically pull harder and harder until he finally unravelled. Because, in the beginning, Fulgrim wasnt really that bad of a guy. However, he kind of had to have that cock like quality to make it happen.

magnus, because he tried so hard to be good, but zeentch was being a butt, poor guy. also I tend to dislike lion because the edgy marines

 dusara217 wrote:
Why Is that selfish bastard the lion so high? Sanguinius is undisputedly the best Primarchs. He's a beast in CC, he's a badass angel with wings, he's an untrained Psyker, he's the first Imperial Farseer, what's not to love?

Cuz he's dead

Definitely Vulkan.
Just read his emergence story. Nocturne was pillaged and enslaved by dark eldar raiders every year, so everyone used to hide. Vulkan however thought screw this and stands with two blacksmiths hammers in the courtyard. He then proceeds to hammer time over a 100 said raiders with hammers.

its also cool that Vulkan is the largest and the strongest of all the primarchs and is capable of overturning Space Marine battle tanks with his bare hands . He is said to be as tall in his power armor as Horus is in his own, much larger Terminator armor. He is also a bit of a mastermind and deeply cares about humans and his legion, unlike SOME primarchs. I guess being a perpertual is a little cool as well.

 redrooster148 wrote:
Definitely Vulkan.
Just read his emergence story. Nocturne was pillaged and enslaved by dark eldar raiders every year, so everyone used to hide. Vulkan however thought screw this and stands with two blacksmiths hammers in the courtyard. He then proceeds to hammer time over a 100 said raiders with hammers.

its also cool that Vulkan is the largest and the strongest of all the primarchs and is capable of overturning Space Marine battle tanks with his bare hands . He is said to be as tall in his power armor as Horus is in his own, much larger Terminator armor. He is also a bit of a mastermind and deeply cares about humans and his legion, unlike SOME primarchs. I guess being a perpertual is a little cool as well.

Is it just me or would Vulkan have been just shot in the face repeatedly if that were actually true?

 dusara217 wrote:

 redrooster148 wrote:
Definitely Vulkan.
Just read his emergence story. Nocturne was pillaged and enslaved by dark eldar raiders every year, so everyone used to hide. Vulkan however thought screw this and stands with two blacksmiths hammers in the courtyard. He then proceeds to hammer time over a 100 said raiders with hammers.

its also cool that Vulkan is the largest and the strongest of all the primarchs and is capable of overturning Space Marine battle tanks with his bare hands . He is said to be as tall in his power armor as Horus is in his own, much larger Terminator armor. He is also a bit of a mastermind and deeply cares about humans and his legion, unlike SOME primarchs. I guess being a perpertual is a little cool as well.

Is it just me or would Vulkan have been just shot in the face repeatedly if that were actually true?

The Dark Eldar probably would have seen a grand prize for their gladiator arenas rather than an actual foe, so its feasible that they didn't just continually shoot him and instead closed the distance hoping to subdue him.

 dusara217 wrote:

 redrooster148 wrote:
Definitely Vulkan.
Just read his emergence story. Nocturne was pillaged and enslaved by dark eldar raiders every year, so everyone used to hide. Vulkan however thought screw this and stands with two blacksmiths hammers in the courtyard. He then proceeds to hammer time over a 100 said raiders with hammers.

its also cool that Vulkan is the largest and the strongest of all the primarchs and is capable of overturning Space Marine battle tanks with his bare hands . He is said to be as tall in his power armor as Horus is in his own, much larger Terminator armor. He is also a bit of a mastermind and deeply cares about humans and his legion, unlike SOME primarchs. I guess being a perpertual is a little cool as well.

Is it just me or would Vulkan have been just shot in the face repeatedly if that were actually true?

It is true. Vulkan had mustered some local townspeople to fight with him but on several sources it says Vulkan killed well over 100 raiders with his blacksmithing hammers alone

 redrooster148 wrote:

 dusara217 wrote:

 redrooster148 wrote:
Definitely Vulkan.
Just read his emergence story. Nocturne was pillaged and enslaved by dark eldar raiders every year, so everyone used to hide. Vulkan however thought screw this and stands with two blacksmiths hammers in the courtyard. He then proceeds to hammer time over a 100 said raiders with hammers.

its also cool that Vulkan is the largest and the strongest of all the primarchs and is capable of overturning Space Marine battle tanks with his bare hands . He is said to be as tall in his power armor as Horus is in his own, much larger Terminator armor. He is also a bit of a mastermind and deeply cares about humans and his legion, unlike SOME primarchs. I guess being a perpertual is a little cool as well.

Is it just me or would Vulkan have been just shot in the face repeatedly if that were actually true?

It is true. Vulkan had mustered some local townspeople to fight with him but on several sources it says Vulkan killed well over 100 raiders with his blacksmithing hammers alone

Ahem, I think you're mistaken. Vulkan clearly had plothammers

 jreilly89 wrote:

 redrooster148 wrote:

 dusara217 wrote:

 redrooster148 wrote:
Definitely Vulkan.
Just read his emergence story. Nocturne was pillaged and enslaved by dark eldar raiders every year, so everyone used to hide. Vulkan however thought screw this and stands with two blacksmiths hammers in the courtyard. He then proceeds to hammer time over a 100 said raiders with hammers.

its also cool that Vulkan is the largest and the strongest of all the primarchs and is capable of overturning Space Marine battle tanks with his bare hands . He is said to be as tall in his power armor as Horus is in his own, much larger Terminator armor. He is also a bit of a mastermind and deeply cares about humans and his legion, unlike SOME primarchs. I guess being a perpertual is a little cool as well.

Is it just me or would Vulkan have been just shot in the face repeatedly if that were actually true?

It is true. Vulkan had mustered some local townspeople to fight with him but on several sources it says Vulkan killed well over 100 raiders with his blacksmithing hammers alone

Ahem, I think you're mistaken. Vulkan clearly had plothammers

Vulkan is immortal. The Dark Eldar could have blasted away with Dark Lances and he'd simply respawn through it. There's nothing they could do to him.

 Wyzilla wrote:

 jreilly89 wrote:

 redrooster148 wrote:

 dusara217 wrote:

 redrooster148 wrote:
Definitely Vulkan.
Just read his emergence story. Nocturne was pillaged and enslaved by dark eldar raiders every year, so everyone used to hide. Vulkan however thought screw this and stands with two blacksmiths hammers in the courtyard. He then proceeds to hammer time over a 100 said raiders with hammers.

its also cool that Vulkan is the largest and the strongest of all the primarchs and is capable of overturning Space Marine battle tanks with his bare hands . He is said to be as tall in his power armor as Horus is in his own, much larger Terminator armor. He is also a bit of a mastermind and deeply cares about humans and his legion, unlike SOME primarchs. I guess being a perpertual is a little cool as well.

Is it just me or would Vulkan have been just shot in the face repeatedly if that were actually true?

It is true. Vulkan had mustered some local townspeople to fight with him but on several sources it says Vulkan killed well over 100 raiders with his blacksmithing hammers alone

Ahem, I think you're mistaken. Vulkan clearly had plothammers

Vulkan is immortal. The Dark Eldar could have blasted away with Dark Lances and he'd simply respawn through it. There's nothing they could do to him.

Exactly. Exalt.

Why like the lion? Like Dark angels are evil as hell but the lion?! He is a pompous ass who kills his own men because he gets pissed when they talk back.

God I hate the lion...

Vulkan is my fav he and his men are equal (in his eyes) and the whole part of him bowing to his men instead of them bowing to him way cool!

I'm glad it's not just me that hate the Lion.

 zombiekila707 wrote:
Why like the lion? Like Dark angels are evil as hell but the lion?! He is a pompous ass who kills his own men because he gets pissed when they talk back.

Source? Never heard him kill his own people other than the traitors. Also, how are they evil? The ones who were tainted by the warp are Chaos now, no longer true DA.


Automatically Appended Next Post:

 ImAGeek wrote:
I'm glad it's not just me that hate the Lion.

So the Lion doesn't get a pass on the hate but Guilliman does?

Source? Never heard him kill his own people other than the traitors. Also, how are they evil? The ones who were tainted by the warp are Chaos now, no longer true DA.

In one of the stories, The Lion Beheads an Astartes for speaking out of turn.

 zombiekila707 wrote:
Why like the lion? Like Dark angels are evil as hell but the lion?! He is a pompous ass who kills his own men because he gets pissed when they talk back.

God I hate the lion...

Vulkan is my fav he and his men are equal (in his eyes) and the whole part of him bowing to his men instead of them bowing to him way cool!

I fething swear, it's like people don't even bother to actually read any Dark Angel books, and instead get everything they know from 1D4Chan. The Lion isn't pompous, he's bipolar. He's perfectly chill most of the time and accepts criticism, only his emotions swing and he lacks any grounding due to spending his childhood in a forest surrounded by Daemons.