Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

After sifting through online chatter, I've uncovered two rumors on Henry Cavill’s Warhammer series—one touting a bold genre shift and another mentioning a dubious choice (IMHO) of leading actor.

I really hate posting on April 1st since it's always dismissed as just another joke, but this story is too intriguing to ignore.


(Plus, the internet has taught me it’s better to be first and factually incorrect than second and forgotten.)

From The Daily Forge.com:

Cavill’s Warhammer Series Takes a Comedic Turn – Reports Claim
According to an unconfirmed report, production insiders hint that Amazon Prime Video may be retooling its upcoming Warhammer series.

Rather than the expected grimdark epic, the project could instead center on the misadventures of Commissar Ciaphas Cain in a surprisingly comedic retelling.

Sources suggest that the change in tone comes from an internal creative shake-up, with the series possibly mixing traditional Warhammer action with moments of humor. However, details remain sketchy, and the report is yet to be verified by other industry insiders.

Stay tuned as we follow this developing story for further updates.

and...

From AtomiKomics.ru:

Breaking News: Henry Cavill’s Warhammer Series Reimagined as Hilarious Epic!

Amazon Prime Video has reportedly taken a dramatic detour with its upcoming Warhammer series, shifting away from the expected grimdark narrative and instead embracing a genre-blending approach. According to sources at Insider-Reports.com, the show will center on the comedic misadventures of Commissar Ciaphas Cain, mixing traditional Warhammer action with unexpected humor.

British comedian and actor Jack Whitehall—known for Bad Education, The Jungle Cruise, and Travels with My Father—has allegedly been cast as Cain, bringing his signature wit to the role. Henry Cavill, who is both producing and starring in the series, reportedly praised the decision, stating, “I’ve always admired Commissar Ciaphas Cain’s unique blend of courage and reluctance. Jack’s humor adds a fresh dimension to Warhammer storytelling.”

While some fans may be surprised by the tonal shift, insiders claim this is part of a broader strategy to expand the franchise’s appeal. Production details remain scarce, and there has been no official confirmation from Amazon.

Stay tuned for more updates as this story develops.

Nice try.

But.

Humiliation

Obvious April Fool is Obvious.

I read this April 2nd thinking 'it could work!'

Seeing as Cain is one of the few parts of Warhammer 40k that remembers that satire is meant to be funny, I wouldn't be opposed to that.

This show idea could work, but not as the first show for 40k. Strikes me as an April fools.

That said, a show where it takes a somewhat comedic turn would absolutely work for Cain. Especially if the entire show's formula was something like this,

Each episode begins with Cain reminiscing about a prior event. Some episodes he is talking to an unseen individual who is interviewing him, and his companions, about his adventures. Others he is simply dictating to a hapless adept who is taking down the story. And yet in others he is simply remembering them himself. Sometimes we see multiple versions of events occur in the episode from different points of view, and which is true is highly debatable. Cain tells an obviously BS version of something that happened, then a recaff mug comes flying from off-camera as the annoyed voice of Amberly Vail says "Thats not how it happened and you know it!!!"

So the whole thing is a somewhat episodic affair with little to no actual overarching story. Just a random series of adventures, some of which might even be true.

 Grey Templar wrote:
This show idea could work, but not as the first show for 40k. Strikes me as an April fools.

That said, a show where it takes a somewhat comedic turn would absolutely work for Cain. Especially if the entire show's formula was something like this,

Each episode begins with Cain reminiscing about a prior event. Some episodes he is talking to an unseen individual who is interviewing him, and his companions, about his adventures. Others he is simply dictating to a hapless adept who is taking down the story. And yet in others he is simply remembering them himself. Sometimes we see multiple versions of events occur in the episode from different points of view, and which is true is highly debatable. Cain tells an obviously BS version of something that happened, then a recaff mug comes flying from off-camera as the annoyed voice of Amberly Vail says "Thats not how it happened and you know it!!!"

So the whole thing is a somewhat episodic affair with little to no actual overarching story. Just a random series of adventures, some of which might even be true.

Eh, that doesn't really fit the character of Cain. He wasn't ever one to actually embellish his own stories, outside the initial lie that earned him his heroic reputation. He learned that instead playing the humble hero and trying to deflect the honour to the real heroes, that is the humble guardsmen and women, worked better for reinforcing his reputation as a hero than any glory hunting.

Also, Amberly Vail often notes that Cain's own memoirs are more critical of himself than often they should be.

But I do think the general gist of episodic adventures with some narration and cutaways by Vail as the "footnotes" and framing device could work.

Only, and I mean only if Framing Cain is done akin to Rowley Birkin




You see, I was very, very drunk.

When one remembers the core reason of the show is to introduce a larger audience to the tabletop game and its many many factions, a comedic and episodic show can do that more easily with short and easily digestible narratives.

I still favour a seasonal approach, starting right down on the macro level.

Pretty much any potential sci-fi audience will “get” Gangs In Spaaaaaaace. Introduce an Inquisitor, see a protagonist recruited as an Acolyte, go from there, expanding out season by season.

Add some modernity ala Game of Thrones and Walking Dead, with no character being safe. Hell, have the lead bumped off ala Roj Blake - and ideally unceremoniously. Make it a Bolt Shell for absolute “yep, they’re not walking that one off” horrid splotchy deff.

 Tyran wrote:
When one remembers the core reason of the show is to introduce a larger audience to the tabletop game and its many many factions, a comedic and episodic show can do that more easily with short and easily digestible narratives.

ehh, idk if comedic is the correct approach to begin with. But episodic and stand alone narratives with recurring characters absolutely.

Its why I've maintained that the first show should follow an Inquisition warband in medium to low stakes encounters to begin with. Perhaps the first few episodes follow the different characters as they get wrapped up in some conspiracy which eventually leads to them being inducted into an Inquisitor's service.

Something like the following characters,

A street urchin trying to survive in the middle hive witnesses a brutal murder, and the perpetrators are trying to silence her to keep it under wraps.

An adept in the lower administratum of the Hive notices some discrepancies, due diligence leading to a shocking discovery.

An Enforcer is trying to solve a string of murder cases, eventually leading him to try and track down the sole witness to the latest one.

A ganger is hired to do a job that seems too good to be true. It was supposed to be easy, pop the target and leave no witnesses. But the target turned the table on him, and now he's in handcuffs across the table from a very brooding man with a Rosette on his chest.

And this group ends up being a warband with the Inquisition and they go on merry adventures with interpersonal growth and conflict as they face various enemies.