Switch Theme:

The Bloodfists (short story)  [RSS] Share on facebook Share on Twitter Submit to Reddit
»
Author Message
Advert


Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you:
  • No adverts like this in the forums anymore.
  • Times and dates in your local timezone.
  • Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance.
  • Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely.
  • Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net.
If you are already a member then feel free to login now.




Made in nl
Werewolf of Angmar




Far over the MistyMountains cold

*cries like never before*

I'm not sure wether that is a sword... it's more like a letteropener, really. 
   
Made in nl
Wight Lord with the Sword of Kings






North of your position

let it die.

   
Made in nl
Werewolf of Angmar




Far over the MistyMountains cold

Goodbye Sergeant Mike Brown. May your soul be in peace.

I'm not sure wether that is a sword... it's more like a letteropener, really. 
   
Made in nl
Wight Lord with the Sword of Kings






North of your position

its not that the Knights of Blood stop

   
Made in nl
Werewolf of Angmar




Far over the MistyMountains cold

so there is going to be a new part?

I'm not sure wether that is a sword... it's more like a letteropener, really. 
   
Made in nl
Wight Lord with the Sword of Kings






North of your position

NOT OF THE STORY, YOU FOOL!

   
Made in nl
Werewolf of Angmar




Far over the MistyMountains cold

Just wanted to anoy you.....did it work?

I'm not sure wether that is a sword... it's more like a letteropener, really. 
   
Made in us
Brainless Servitor





Georgia, USA

Ah, if i can interupt you two, i have some critique for this story.
Overall, it's good. I like it. However, there are some major problems in the story, primarily having to do with the ship and the interactions with it by the SMs.

First off, i think almost any Tau ship would have a hanger bay for gunships and landers and the like, which the SMs could enter through. However, this isnt particularly important as they decided to blow their way into the ship. This though segues into the next problem: They blew a hole in the ship, and there was no decompression. This might not make a difference for the SMs as they have helmets, but most of the Tau would have been sucked out of the hole.
Next, the Multi-melta would have most certainly have melted the blast door, instead of simply blackening the paint. I think the last part is that the SMs could not have landed a Thunderhawk in the bridge of any ship. Perhaps it could have held in place while the SMs got out, but it's far to big to land.

Combat now. While in general, it was fine, but at times it seemed a little jerky. For example, in the bridge, after most of the Crisis Suits were killed by the rocket, what happened to the Ethereal? I didnt see anything about him. Which leads me to another issue. Any force that is boarding a ship will not be using rocket lanchers. Simply too much danger to their own men.\
I wouldnt change it here, as the RLs make up a big part of the combat and i wouldnt wanna go back and change the combat around for that, but simply as a note for the future: the corridors are far too cramped on a ship for using rocket launchers.

Finally, I come to more lore related issues. Firstly, there are no female SMs. This is a common misconception, so dont feel bad about it. While you dont explicitly say that the girl(my apologies, i forget her name) is a SM, you dont say she isnt. Specifying that she is a sister of battle, or even an Inquisitor, would clarify things.
Nextly, i need to ask what an Ethereal is doing on one random Tau ship in the Unnamedius System(my word for unspecified systems in 40k stories). Ethereals are the most revered beings in the Tau Empire and any Ethereal would have at the very least a small battlefleet accompanying him. Again, just something to think about in the future.

Two more general issues, which can really make or break stories.
First, you need to be more descriptive. I know that a lot of readers prefer authors who make it clear what is going on in the story and give fairly detailed descriptions of the places and characters. It helps to make the story more intersting and imaginable. This one though, i can forgive since English isnt your first language. I dont know, perhaps your stories are very descriptive in Dutch and the only reason they arnt in English is a limited vocabulary, i can't know.

Lastly, an easy oversight but again important for writing. When you write, make sure you start a new line when you have a new speaker in dialogue and new paragraphs. I hate it and i know others hate it when an otherwise good story is difficult to read because the author didnt start new lines. The story simply becomes a wall of words that is very unenjoyable to read. Even if you dont listen to anything else i've said, please try to follow these last two things, they are so important to a good story.

Ok, i've said my peice . Remember these are all suggestiions, you dont have to follow them if you dont want to. I'd be happy to make a more detailed critique later if you want later, but this is the important stuff.

And when he gets to Heaven, to St. Peter he will tell. 'One more soldier reporting for duty. I've served my time in Hell.'
The Essential Space Marine Commandments:
Thou shalt not do Spock impersonations around Eldar
Thou shalt not refer to the Rhino transports as "pimp wagons," nor shalt thou use the phrase, "If the Rhino be rockin, don't come a knockin."
Thou shall not ask a Sister if you might "donate some of your own Gene-Seed."
Thou shalt not unplug the Golden Throne just "for laughs".
Thou shalt Not unplug the Golden Throne just "for laughs".
Thou shalt NOT unplug the Golden Throne just "for laughs".
My Stories:The Emperor's Justice
Dreadnought
Fluff: Eternal Watchers 
   
Made in nl
Werewolf of Angmar




Far over the MistyMountains cold

More detailed than this?

I'm not sure wether that is a sword... it's more like a letteropener, really. 
   
Made in nl
Wight Lord with the Sword of Kings






North of your position

Thanks for critics, I will certainly use them
Anyways, it is based on my army and the characters (names) people give them We just dont give females any geneseed, but give them some nice all-round bionics (or bioniks, for that matter). Anyways, its good to have critics, I will listen to them, and thanks for the input

   
Made in nl
Werewolf of Angmar




Far over the MistyMountains cold

I think his vocabulary isnt that limited... He and i are like the best of the class.......right thenoobbomb?
Thats because, he goes to england quite often, and i have an australian father. When he's at home, wespeak a lotof english....so i dont doubt that....even though he is very descriptive in dutch....

I'm not sure wether that is a sword... it's more like a letteropener, really. 
   
Made in us
Brainless Servitor





Georgia, USA

When i say more detailed, i was talking about grammar issues and spelling. Glad you appreciate it, i enjoy doing this stuff. And while it is a bit unfair to say limited, but there are better ways to say things occasionally.

And when he gets to Heaven, to St. Peter he will tell. 'One more soldier reporting for duty. I've served my time in Hell.'
The Essential Space Marine Commandments:
Thou shalt not do Spock impersonations around Eldar
Thou shalt not refer to the Rhino transports as "pimp wagons," nor shalt thou use the phrase, "If the Rhino be rockin, don't come a knockin."
Thou shall not ask a Sister if you might "donate some of your own Gene-Seed."
Thou shalt not unplug the Golden Throne just "for laughs".
Thou shalt Not unplug the Golden Throne just "for laughs".
Thou shalt NOT unplug the Golden Throne just "for laughs".
My Stories:The Emperor's Justice
Dreadnought
Fluff: Eternal Watchers 
   
Made in nl
Werewolf of Angmar




Far over the MistyMountains cold

Well, its good that you enjoy what you do.

I'm not sure wether that is a sword... it's more like a letteropener, really. 
   
 
Forum Index » Dakka Fiction
Go to: