Snrub wrote:They at least cite their sources.
Though they don't always say what the article suggests.
Snrub wrote:Don't just allow fan fiction to run rampent.
Technically, any fan-fiction is just as valid as anything official - that's what Gav Thorpe himself said, anyways. What really does run rampant in the community is the erroneous belief that there is such a thing as a uniform "canon" truth, ignoring the blatant contradictions between the various sources. Which is something Lexicanum is at fault for propagating.
I still like it for an index of sorts, though. My personal recommendation is looking up the sources on Lexicanum, and then reading those. The fan-edited wiki articles tend to try and merge them all into one piece of knowledge, even when the sources were never intended to tie into each other. Thus, the articles become a sort of fan-fiction themselves. On some pages, they've begun to have a special "canon conflicts" section for it, but on others it's all just mashed into one thing reflecting the editor's personal interpretation.
OnTopic: Planetary Defense Forces, at least in
GW's own material, can be just about anything the Imperial Guard itself has, or perhaps even more (given that they may utilise local vehicle and weapon variants, and have their own air support, unlike the
IG which has to rely on the Imperial Navy for that). What a PDF actually has, however, will depend heavily on the individual world. On one planet, the PDF's "Kill Squad" will be some feral chieftain's Viking-like personal enforcers armed with chainmail and broadswords, whereas on the next you've got carapace-armoured troopers wielding heavy stubbers and shock batons. And then you've got anything in-between!