Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

Inquisitor remains my favourite GW game ever. Really captures the level of detail you get in something like the Eisenhorn books. Down to the individual rounds loaded in the gun. I still get 1 or 2 games a year in. Have lots of 54mm models as well for painting and modelling. BUT. It will never make a comeback. Its to in depth and detailed for GW to sustain any interest in and too complex and detailed for most people these days.

If BFG was done properly i would be interested in playing. And by properly i mean, all races, all ships, full models and supported rule set. Not "set it in the horus heresy so we can make you buy the same ships twice, paint one blue, one red and call it a game".

 H.B.M.C. wrote:
You could give the snarky answer and say "Necromunda", given what modern Necromunda has turned into.

That's kind of how I feel about AI, they brought it back but the gameplay is a big step down over what it used to be.

For a game that wasn't perfect but only needed a few tweaks, they sure did mess it up.

I really like new Necromunda, especially after GotU.
I think the most recent book releases have really taken it in a direction I disagree with though.

Definitely agree on Aeronautica, it's a shame as the new models look absolutely superb.

I miss Battlefleet Gothic so much. I got the starter set when I was a kid and loved it to bits. However I didn't really know about forge world and special orders back then, so I was waiting patiently for more models to come to my FLGS that never did. I would love to take a crack at this game again.

Is Aeronautica discontinued? I literally just bought a starter set for it last week. It looks like a lot of fun.

BFG all day

I miss Battlefleet Gothic, I only ever got the starter set, but it was a blast. I'd love to see a plastic line with proper support. I'd be all over that.

Is Aeronautica discontinued now? I literally just bought the starter set last week, it looked really interesting.

I really like the direction Necromunda has taken, and think the new books add so much to the game; I'm excited to see where it will go in the future.
BFG would be an auto-buy, as long as it's a full game with models for all of the main factions. AI was such a let-down. The new models are stunning, but the game is a giant step down from the previous version and the strange decision not to release Chaos models means it feels incomplete to me.

Battlefleet Gothic for me. Void warfare is just as important logistically as ground warfare in terms of narrative.

I loved Warmaster. But before my army was ready, it was over again. Now the stuff is lying around unfinished.

Now that Epic has returned, I want to see BFG return as well. It'd be awesome to play a multi-system Campaign using BFG, Epic and 28mil models, BFG would complete the trifecta

I had a lot of fun with BFG and still have my Eldar fleet. But if the game ends up being Battlefleet: Heresy as rumored...I don't really see myself getting into it.

I don't want anything else return the way "Epic" did.

 Eilif wrote:
Necromunda. Though there's really no reason to wait around for GW. Lots of opportunities for proxies and the rules are still free. Our club is starting a campaign next meeting using Yaktribe's "Necromunda Community Edition" (NCE) verison.
http://gaming.yaktribe.org/community/vault/categories/necromunda.2/

How naive I was in 2015. Thinking that GW could do a tight redo of a fantastic game. As opposed to the rules-bloated mess they came up with that I dropped after a box set and 4 "Gang Wars".

Ironically, my advice remains roughly the same. Skip NewCrowMunda and go for NCE .

Now as the club turns toward a summer Mordheim campaign, I'm torn between thinking it would be a great setting for GW to revisit but knowing full well I'd likely not be interested in the result.

 Eilif wrote:

 Eilif wrote:
Necromunda. Though there's really no reason to wait around for GW. Lots of opportunities for proxies and the rules are still free. Our club is starting a campaign next meeting using Yaktribe's "Necromunda Community Edition" (NCE) verison.
http://gaming.yaktribe.org/community/vault/categories/necromunda.2/

How naive I was in 2015. Thinking that GW could do a tight redo of a fantastic game. As opposed to the rules-bloated mess they came up with that I dropped after a box set and 4 "Gang Wars".

Ironically, my advice remains roughly the same. Skip NewCrowMunda and go for NCE .

Now as the club turns toward a summer Mordheim campaign, I'm torn between thinking it would be a great setting for GW to revisit but knowing full well I'd likely not be interested in the result.

Hmm I'm having trouble finding Necromunda CE

Checking in.
After a summer campaign of Mordheim, my opinion is reinforced that it's a fantastic game, dripping with flavor that makes no pretentions about perfect balance and is the stronger for it.

I'd love to see them put together a big book of Mordheim -virtually untouched as far as rules- pulling together the into one volume the best of the massive amounts of material that was published for the game in Town Cryer and similar publications. GW has the copyright to all of it and it would be easy enough to do.

Just give us the rules, scenarios, and warbands in one big book and let us do the rest ourselves*.


*aka don't #^&% it up like Necromunda.

BanjoJohn wrote:


Hmm I'm having trouble finding Necromunda CE

For anyone who may be looking, it's here:
https://yaktribe.games/community/vault/necromunda-community-edition-rulebook.1/updates#resource-update-1390

But you do have to have a forum account to download.

My current list is


Epic A (no LI doesn't count)
Man O War
Battlefleet gothic (we now have 6 regular players at club...)
Warhammer quest (no the reboot didn't work)
Mordhiem (though given it is terrain heavy and they have warcry, will never happen)