Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

 Iron_Captain wrote:

 BioVass wrote:

 Iron_Captain wrote:


Secondly the time line does not add up. In 40k, Slaanesh was born in M30. The Primarchs were also created at this time. Sigmar was born 5600 years after Chaos (already including Slaanesh) first appeared in the Fantasy universe and therefore can not be a Primarch unless he stayed on Terra for 5600 years after being created while also still being an infant.

Time. Is. Different. In. Warp. There's even Ordo Chronos in Inquisition that deals with these time anomallies. Also chaos gods think they all were born at the same time or always existed.

In the Warp yes. Not in the physical universe. In the Warp, Slaanesh may have always existed, but that does not change the fact that he was born only in M30. By the laws of the physical universe, he can not possibly have existed or influenced it before that time.
Whatever the Ordo Chronos does is unknown. Also, they have all disappeared, so there is no more Ordo Chronos.

 Iron_Captain wrote:
By the laws of the physical universe

Holy elephant of doom, Y NO UNDERSTAND? Warp screws up ing everythyng from physical world - time, space, common sense, cookies.

40K is so huge you can fit pretty much fit any fantasy setting in it into it . For example Game Of Thrones is just some planet in the 40k galaxy, theory the Lanisters and Starks were just human followers of the space wolves and dark angels. Dragon age could follow this same idea, the fade is just the warp. However crazy forced conspiracies aside there is a great deal of proof that fantasy is a world in the 40k galaxy. The definitive proof comes in two events. First when the Skaven looted the Lizard men's cities they came across a device that was essentially a communication relay that they used to speak with Eldar. Secondly Kaldor Draigo is popping up randomly saving the day. So yup it's official kinda, my theory is that Archaon didn't blow up the world, some inquisitor just came by saw what was happening and said "Dayum there's a lot heresy, orks, xenos down there, good thing I got here before they discovered space travel"

 chazz huggins wrote:
Secondly Kaldor Draigo is popping up randomly saving the day

Whut? what piece of fluff is that?

 BioVass wrote:

 chazz huggins wrote:
Secondly Kaldor Draigo is popping up randomly saving the day

Whut? what piece of fluff is that?

In End Times Khaine (which is coincidentally the last thing Matt Ward ever wrote for GW) a silver knight of great size drops in out of nowhere and kicks Nurglite ass

 BioVass wrote:

 Iron_Captain wrote:

 BioVass wrote:

 Iron_Captain wrote:


Secondly the time line does not add up. In 40k, Slaanesh was born in M30. The Primarchs were also created at this time. Sigmar was born 5600 years after Chaos (already including Slaanesh) first appeared in the Fantasy universe and therefore can not be a Primarch unless he stayed on Terra for 5600 years after being created while also still being an infant.

Time. Is. Different. In. Warp. There's even Ordo Chronos in Inquisition that deals with these time anomallies. Also chaos gods think they all were born at the same time or always existed.

In the Warp yes. Not in the physical universe. In the Warp, Slaanesh may have always existed, but that does not change the fact that he was born only in M30. By the laws of the physical universe, he can not possibly have existed or influenced it before that time.
Whatever the Ordo Chronos does is unknown. Also, they have all disappeared, so there is no more Ordo Chronos.

 Iron_Captain wrote:
By the laws of the physical universe

Holy elephant of doom, Y NO UNDERSTAND? Warp screws up ing everythyng from physical world - time, space, common sense, cookies.

Yes, but only if it can break through to the physical world. Something in the Warp can not influence the physical world on its own. Look at the Chaos Gods, for example. They need worshippers and mortal servants in the physical universe, otherwise they could not influence it at all. Same with deamons, they need to be summoned using physical objects, or they must possess a physical body to be able to influence the physical universe. The Warp can only influence the physical universe directly once a Warp gate opens, which again has to be done by something in the physical universe.
Also, please keep the Warp away from my cookies, I rather like cookies. Especially biscuits. Nice biscuits.

 Iron_Captain wrote:

Not really. The Warp can't influence the physical universe directly.

The giant space butt hole the space elves made would disagree.

also the minor rash that is the maelstrom.