Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

BrotherStynier wrote:

Manchu wrote:Ah, perhaps Stynier would recognize his name. Stynier was at the Schola, you know.

Indeed I was, perhaps we attended the same Schola? What was your grandfather's name Oblitr8r?

I'm not sure if you met him. He was Colonel Janssen of the Cadian 23rd.

You said he was a Commissar...

Maybe he's like Gaunt.

BrotherStynier wrote:Gornall, the simple farmer seems to be more than that. Have you ever met a simple farmer that insists on reason or logic? I think not.

My many years of farming taught me that moaning about the drought doesn't water the crops. It's best to think the problem through and either dig an aqueduct or grab a bucket and start hauling.

Here are my notes:
LoG: Dead(my only reservation is if he might be a sanctioned pysker who is just addled). (We know how that turned out)
Manchu: I see no current problems with his story or actions. My one concern is he is almost too active, but the same could be said about myself.
DarkO: His actions earlier would either make him the smartest or the absolute dumbest Xenos ever. Manchu makes a convincing argument about his "sacrifice", however. I am not above voting for him if a more suitable suspect is not found.
Orkesaurus: His story of survival with no limbs seems somewhat suspect. I'm still unsure of his voting pattern.
Ultrafool: I do not know what to make of his story about his hidden "brother". They could be the very traitors themselves. He has also been very quiet of late, possibly laying low.
Mekboy: Dead
Valhallan: He was the last person to vote for DarkO/LoG... he also seems to vote with Orkesaurus regularly.
Dark Lord Seanron: He was quick to throw DarkO under the bus when things were first heating up against LoG
Airman: He wanted to dispose of the body... also, no rhyme or reason to his voting patterns other than jumping on wagons.
Stynier: I see no current problems with his story or actions. Seems to be very focused on Airman.
Gwar!: He is almost too quiet. He only seems to talk as he is casting a vote for whoever has the most votes. And he still smells like troll.
Demogerg: He seems to know too much about the heretical Xenos. However most of what he says seems to make sense. I am unsure of his voting patterns.
Lord-Loss: He follows everyone elses votes way too much. Specifically he seems to follow Valhallan quite a bit.
Frenzied Potato: He also has been too quiet.

I'm having a difficult time keeping up with all the voting changes, and I think that is probably intentional by the Xenos. The more they muddy the waters, the harder it is for us to determine their true intentions. Further, I do not know what if any conclusions we can draw from Mekboy's murder. I think it is still early in the voyage, so it is quite possible the Xenos picked someone at random rather than risk tipping their hands.

BrotherStynier wrote:You said he was a Commissar...

My mother told me he was...

Drk_Oblitr8r wrote:

BrotherStynier wrote:You said he was a Commissar...

My mother told me he was...

Wait Drk_Oblitr8r, you said your father was a commissar, than Stynier said what was your grandfathers name, you replied, then he said that you said he was a commissar,and than you said your mom told me so.

So who is the commissar your father of your grandfather?

Gornall,

Let me establish my voting pattern for you:

I vote for people I think might be genestealers.

Like Airman.

Ultrafool wrote:So who is the commissar your father of your grandfather?

Drk_Oblitr8r wrote:She'd be even happier than if I was there caring for her, because all my life she wanted me to be brave, like her father, he was a Commisar.

So supposedly your grandfather was the Commissar.

Oh Sorry I was confused.

BrotherStynier wrote:So supposedly your grandfather was the Commissar.

Mhmmm....

[loading data spool] Subject: Baal - Millennia before the founding of the Imperium, Baal and its two moons were all but destroyed by in a terrible war. Ancient viral and nuclear weapons had turned the once idyllic worlds into toxic wastelands. The survivors became scavengers, constantly moving from places to places, and warring to preserve the spoils they gathered.

Baal's two moons are designated Baal Primus and Baal Secundus, from which the Astartes Blood Angels take their new recruits {clarification required}

In ancient days Baal and its moons had earth-like atmospheres. Baal itself was always a world of red rust deserts, but its moons were close to paradises. As the Dark Age of Technology (Omnissiah preserve us) ended in the Age of Strife, civil war erupted between the world and its colonised moons, leading to the nuclear devastation of the planets.

Baal Secundus has since been a nuclear-blasted desert world with deadly levels of radiation. This forced the world's human tribes to build cumbersome radiation suits in order to survive. Mutants were once rife upon the world, frequently at war with the remaining pure humans for dominance of the planet.

[conclusion] hardly a suitable locale to find a commisar, or even for one to settle his family down upon. Indeed, unless your grandfather was a mutant posing as a commisar or he and your mother had a disagreement that had her shipped to Baal as punishment, I find your story highly suspect...

[furthermore] you are quoted as stating your Father was Cadian. How can it be that someone from Cadia came to Father yourself with a woman from Baal? Cadia is part of the Segmentum Obscurus, whilst Baal is in the Ultima Segmentum. Baal's system itself has no standing PDF or Imperial Guard, however is policed by the Astartes, so the likliehood of a Cadian regiment (Cadians being loath to leave their homeworld undefended) being within 240 parsecs of Baal is highly dubious. Your stories and answers do not add up Obitr8r.

[furthermore] Also, surely fraternisation with a Commisar's daughter is something the usually strictly disciplined and loyal soldiers of Cadia would not do...

Gornal, I voted for LOG cause I thought he was a rogue pyker.

I voted for Drk_Oblit because he was acting strange, trying to make himself less suspicous.

I voted for Airman because He wanted to dispose of the evidence and voted 'no:Lynch'.

OOC: So quiet today...

OOC: busy at work, stupid halloween sale.

(OOC:going on camping trip, will be gone for two days.)

-Turns to the people who haven't voted-

So, are you just gonna sit there with your jaws flapping all day or are you actually gonna do something to protect the ship?

A bit blood thirsty are we, Gwar!?

Still, just because we have three terran standard weeks, doesn't mean we need to use those weeks.

Manchu wrote:Frenzied is voting for me. I addressed his reason more than adequately, in my opinion. He did not himself challenge my arguments but his vote stands. I don't know what to make of that.

<OOC> Long day havnt got to posting that and Tekken 6 came out very sorry.

UNVOTE: MANCHU


My reasoning was in the previous argument I made. I believe this is what Mekboy intended and I can see why he would have "if" he was allowed. Especially if I die following suit.

Drk_Oblitr8r wrote:It does.

I changed my vote to you, because I FELT that you were, I don't know if you were, but I'm guessing you weren't now, but you haven't really said.

I changed my vote to no lynch because I was angry, and voting for no one to die is the quickest way to let someone die. I'm sorry for doing so for this reason.

So you changed your vote to no lynch because you believe it is the quickest way for someone to die?

Explain yourself.

In my eyes and the reasoning from my previous arguement I will follow Mekboy's line of thought I believe he had. Airman or You Drk_Oblit.

I don't know that either of them can or will explain themselves any better than they already have. My instinct tells me that Airman is involved, and that Drk_Oblit is not. But you may come to a different answer.

I realise that I am one of the most suspected people so far, but because of this, many have escaped suspicion almost purely by luck (As Manchu said). I as someone who hates luck, I think we have to try and find out more about everyone else.

DLS, I would think that you of all people should know my grand father. He should be in at least your records.(OOC:He's from actual fluff)

Frenzied Potato wrote:

Drk_Oblitr8r wrote:It does.

I changed my vote to you, because I FELT that you were, I don't know if you were, but I'm guessing you weren't now, but you haven't really said.

I changed my vote to no lynch because I was angry, and voting for no one to die is the quickest way to let someone die. I'm sorry for doing so for this reason.

So you changed your vote to no lynch because you believe it is the quickest way for someone to die?

Explain yourself.

In my eyes and the reasoning from my previous arguement I will follow Mekboy's line of thought I believe he had. Airman or You Drk_Oblit.

My comment explained itself. Please, listen to what I say before you decide you're against it.

Just incase it's still unclear.

Dark Lord Seanron wrote:[furthermore] you are quoted as stating your Father was Cadian. How can it be that someone from Cadia came to Father yourself with a woman from Baal? Cadia is part of the Segmentum Obscurus, whilst Baal is in the Ultima Segmentum. Baal's system itself has no standing PDF or Imperial Guard, however is policed by the Astartes, so the likliehood of a Cadian regiment (Cadians being loath to leave their homeworld undefended) being within 240 parsecs of Baal is highly dubious. Your stories and answers do not add up Obitr8r.

[furthermore] Also, surely fraternisation with a Commisar's daughter is something the usually strictly disciplined and loyal soldiers of Cadia would not do...

Drk_Oblitr8r wrote:

Ultrafool wrote:So who is the commissar your father of your grandfather?

Drk_Oblitr8r wrote:She'd be even happier than if I was there caring for her, because all my life she wanted me to be brave, like her father, he was a Commisar.

Bolded the importantest part.

I have made no mention of my father, because as I have said

Drk_Oblitr8r wrote:

Lord-Loss wrote:Wouldnt your dad be ashamed, that only after two people died, you stopped acting like a child?

I'm ashamed of my father, I've never known him.

I haven't even heard about him. Even when I asked my mother she would look at me with a look of fear, which was a rare occurance for her, and if she was scared, then you'd have to realise how scary that was for me. I only ever asked twice.

I still think DarkO to be too obvious. I am not convinced of Airman's guilt however. Currently my focus lies on Lord-Loss as he seems to follow Valhallan's lead on votes. That and both of them seemed very defensive about my notes. However, that is just a nagging thought and I do not have enough evidence to back it up.

Still, a decision has to be made, one way or the other. Even deciding not to take out a suspected xenos is a decision.

I still say that I am right and Airman is a prime suspect.

OOC: We have a lot of time here don't we?

OOC: Yes, AND my ADD is making me WANT TO FORCE CHOKE PEOPLE. And I mean that in the most loving way possible.

Once again allow me to say I too believe we should take out Airman...

How about we just vote for someone, the more time we waste thinking about what we're going to do, the more likely the genestealers reach Holy Terra.

VOTE: airman

Drk Oblit, have you voted since the last official vote tally? Since you're on the St. Laura Roslin Expressway to Airlock City, you might want to excercise your sufferage prior to arrival.

EDIT: Ninja'ed. Still, the above comment is funny, so it stays.