Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

Samus_aran115 wrote:Sanguinus was pretty homosex, IMO. With his meaningless sacrifice, he doomed his entire legion for the rest of eternity.

The blood angels are no better than mutants, afaic.

Meaningless? MEANINLESS? I"M SO RAGED RIGHT NOW! ARRRRGGGHH!!!!!!
Seriously, his sacrifice saved the imperium. If not for the chink in Horus' armor (caused by Sangy) the Emprah would have lost.
Whats your favorite primarch then? I'll make my ranking of him especially harsh >:[


Automatically Appended Next Post:

Asherian Command wrote:

Asgeirr Darkwolf wrote:Yeah, it's very sad. Like the bromance in there (but kinda not... its more like respect.)

yeah the lion and the wolf are too really good primarchs.

Ehhh, not so much


Automatically Appended Next Post:
Also, just because I love Sangy, It doesn't guarantee him to be first, so you all know.

Asgeirr Darkwolf wrote:Hmm... I just dislik the lion, mostly cause he was too busy dealing with his own guys in the heresy,

No, he wasn't. Horus made sure to send the Dark Angles to the Shield Worlds with the Space Wolfs. He was afraid of Jonson's tactical might. Jonson didn't return to Caliban until many years after the HH.

Little lord Fauntleroy wrote:

Asgeirr Darkwolf wrote:Yeah, LLF, you were first... don't rub it in... we all praise you for that great idea (and then sneakilly copy it!)

Not rubbing in, just hopelessly attempting to assert my fragile ego.

battle Brother Lucifer wrote:You won't be waiting for long!

16: Lorgar.

I was right? I was right! Hmm...next primarch is Lion.


My god I'm turning into Ediin.

No, because you are actually guessing correctly.

Alright, next one's Horus.

Reading First Heretic atm and i dont mind the Word Bearers, while they are been seekers (suckers) for the Truth, they are at least more interesting than later on in dark disciple "worship.worship.worship"

Dorn and Guilliman are a bit too perfect. They need faults to make them interesting. So they belong where they are.

Should have had 2nd and 11th primarchs in this list. Sure we know nothing about them, but makes them more interesting than a few primarchs

ChaosGalvatron wrote:Reading First Heretic atm and i dont mind the Word Bearers, while they are been seekers (suckers) for the Truth, they are at least more interesting than later on in dark disciple "worship.worship.worship"

Dorn and Guilliman are a bit too perfect. They need faults to make them interesting. So they belong where they are.

Should have had 2nd and 11th primarchs in this list. Sure we know nothing about them, but makes them more interesting than a few primarchs

Ture, but that would be unfair for a bunch of the others . You guys are going to see soon, the I only *like* a few primarchs.
There are some others I don't mind, and then most I dislike all the way.

does anyone like Guillimans dictating ass? Nice choice to start things rolling.

I'm sure his mummy loves him very much.

The Laughing God is pleased with your choices.

My only gripe is you seem to be a bit dissorganized with weather your rating primarchs/legions/both. Little more consistency please.

^ Will do. Rankings in a few (to about 20ish) minutes

20 minutes?

Next legion is...erm...Iron hands?

battle Brother Lucifer wrote:

Samus_aran115 wrote:Sanguinus was pretty homosex, IMO. With his meaningless sacrifice, he doomed his entire legion for the rest of eternity.

The blood angels are no better than mutants, afaic.

Meaningless? MEANINLESS? I"M SO RAGED RIGHT NOW! ARRRRGGGHH!!!!!!
Seriously, his sacrifice saved the imperium. If not for the chink in Horus' armor (caused by Sangy) the Emprah would have lost.
Whats your favorite primarch then? I'll make my ranking of him especially harsh

Blablahblah. Meaningless details

Leman Russ.

Actually Samus, unlike his legion, I kinda like Russ
. I've kinda dug myself a hole here, while writing my list there are primarchs I dislike more than Russ, so his rank gets pushed up higher. Ah well.

And the few minutes to possibly twenty minutes is how fast I can finish correcting and printing my paper due tomorrow.
I know Wargaming takes precedence over most of my life choices, but unfortunately, not work I can't get out of. (The paper is worth two tests so...)
Also, I only had like, 3 mistakes on it, so I'll write it up in a minute. The rest of the possible 20 minutes is how long it takes me to ramble on and fix up my rankings

battle Brother Lucifer wrote:Actually Samus, unlike his legion, I kinda like Russ
. I've kinda dug myself a hole here, while writing my list there are primarchs I dislike more than Russ, so his rank gets pushed up higher. Ah well.

And the few minutes to possibly twenty minutes is how fast I can finish correcting and printing my paper due tomorrow.
I know Wargaming takes precedence over most of my life choices, but unfortunately, not work I can't get out of. (The paper is worth two tests so...)
Also, I only had like, 3 mistakes on it, so I'll write it up in a minute. The rest of the possible 20 minutes is how long it takes me to ramble on and fix up my rankings

Yeah, me too. He's a pretty cool guy, but his legion?ehhhh. *shrugs*

Wow. I just spend the past number of minutes since my last post frantically tearing through my house looking for my flash drive, but I found it.
It was underneath all my ork sprues
Looks like gaming is trying to take precedence

Update in a few

What? How could you not like Furry- VIking- Werewolf- Tribal- Space- Supermen- Wolf- Marines? ....Oh wait.

Yeah, I can see why some don't like them, but hte reason I chose them is not their codex, but cause I love their fluff- unlike the BA, their Curse only makes them better, and they don't go whinig about it...

As for Russ? He's pretty awesome in every way, except his unshakeable faith- listening to horus telling him to kill a borther? Really?

Even so, his legion's great in my view. Say what you will about the current 'dex (Thunderwolves? Really? Riding giant wolves now?) but fluff wise, thier kinda a really cool legion. Beneath all their badassery, they just need a hug... NOT! Plus, they got cool hair and beards, and have certain... er... privileges that regular marines don't. (Just look at the Trickster).

I wish we'd hear more about the 13th company or the curse of the wolfen, that would cement them in my mind forever as the coolest legion.

...Wow. That was a long fan rant. Sorry bout that!

Just to tease you guys, You'll never guess who my number one rank is. You can try, but I don't think you will.

Well, As I promised: 15: Lion El'johnson

Lions and wolves and 7-foot tall armored space marines Oh My! Well, there are some things I like about the Lion, Within a decade, he led an army and cleared his planet of the 'great beasts', which I think is a pretty big accomplishment. He knocked Russ out cold, which I think is pretty funny, and awesome. He 'preformed a master stroke' and against unfavorable odds, captured the siege weapons Horus would have used againsts Terra. Pretty awesome. However, he traded them to Perturabo to further his goal of becoming the new warmaster. (which definitely would have gone to Sangy anyway, btw. Horus said so himself) This was a dumb move in to ways. First, he traded away the weapons only to further his own goals, and the heresy wasn't even over. Though he couldn't have known, Perturabo was a traitor, and he just handed him the weapons he just fought for.Then, after bombing Caliban, Johnson declared nap time and is sleeping in (Dawyne) The Rock (Johnson) (ha, I made a joke. Get it? Lion el'Johnson. Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson.)
Anyway, now time to actually rant a bit. I dislike Johnson a whole lot. He did do a few cool things, but most of his actions during and after the heresy are unrecorded, or spent doing crap with his own legion. He thought he could have been warmaster, which is kinda dumb, and thought about it before Horus was even defeated. He left/ sent a ton of his chapter back on Caliban, which I also think wasn't a good idea. Also, I kinda picture Johnson as the cowardly Lion from Wizzard of Oz, but whatever

Writers block right now, I need to figure out what chapter I'm going to rank.

For the first rank Imma guessing either Russ (except not) or... ALPHARIUS!

All that aside, the biggest underdogs would be Peturabo or Fulgrim or Ferrus Mannus...

But the likely choices are:

My favorite, Konrad Cuze the Dark Knight.

Mortation

Vulkan!

Asgeirr Darkwolf wrote:For the first rank Imma guessing either Russ (except not) or... ALPHARIUS!

All that aside, the biggest underdogs would be Peturabo or Fulgrim or Ferrus Mannus...

But the likely choices are:

My favorite, Konrad Cuze the Dark Knight.

Mortation

Vulkan!

One of the Primarchs you mentioned may be number one

Okay... then the most likely is... KONRAD CUZE! Gotta love him, man.

Corax...Corax...Corax...

Asgeirr Darkwolf wrote:Okay... then the most likely is... KONRAD CUZE! Gotta love him, man.

He's in the top five, but not number one. Thats all I'm saying.

Alright, I'll keep my guesses to meself for now, but Ill write them down so I know what I thought.

You can pm me your guesses, but if you guess correctly, I won't tell you.
(can't ruin the surprise)

Nah... it's like Christmas, don't open the presents before it's time!

Vulkan will be no. 1.

Little lord Fauntleroy wrote:Vulkan will be no. 1.

In your (and every Salamanders player's) dreams

So Vulkan and Kurze are out....maybe Fulgrim?

Maybe
You'll have to wait and see. Update after dinner

Konrad was assassinated...what a lame primarch.

battle Brother Lucifer wrote:

Little lord Fauntleroy wrote:Vulkan will be no. 1.

In your (and every Salamanders player's) dreams

If I say it enough times, maybe it'll become true.