Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

Genestealer wrote:@Deff Dread: You've said that before as well. You might want to get some sleep, mate.

It is undeniable that TLOG is using scummy logic. Whether this is just him being scummy, or him being a scummy genestealer is nowhere near as clear.

How about we lynch him and found out? (I love Imperial logic )

Hmmm.... Let's all kill the guy with the bolter!!
Vote:Emperors Faithful

Edit: [b/] to [/b]

Ye Olde Vote Accounting

0 - n0t_u
0 - Vulkan_He'stan
0 - Mekboy
2 - lord of the ghosts (Mekboy Emperor's Faithful)
1 - BrotherStynier (ginger_nid_dude)
0 - Deff Dread red Edition
0 - Fifty
1 - Emperor's Faithul (lord of the ghosts)
0 - Rusty Knight
1 - Drk_O ( Dark Lord Seanron )
4 - the_ferrett (Gornall Drk_O Rusty Knight n0t_u )
1 - ginger_nid_dude (Fifty )
0 - Lord-Loss
1 - Dark Lord Seanron ( Lord-Loss)
0 - Gornall

0 - No Lynch

Not Voting: BrotherStynier Deff Dread red Edition Vulkan_He'stan the_ferrett

With 15 alive it is 8 to Lynch
If the deadline were to hit now - the_ferrett would be lynched
Deadline countdown

lord of the ghosts wrote:

Genestealer wrote:@Deff Dread: You've said that before as well. You might want to get some sleep, mate.

It is undeniable that TLOG is using scummy logic. Whether this is just him being scummy, or him being a scummy genestealer is nowhere near as clear.

How about we lynch him and found out? (I love Imperial logic )

Hmmm.... Let's all kill the guy with the bolter!!
Vote:Emperors Faithful

Edit: [b/] to [/b]

I see what you did there...

Drk_Oblitr8r wrote:

lord of the ghosts wrote:

Genestealer wrote:
It is undeniable that TLOG is using scummy logic. Whether this is just him being scummy, or him being a scummy genestealer is nowhere near as clear.
How about we lynch him and found out? (I love Imperial logic )

I see what you did there...

OOC:Isn't that cool?
EDIT:quote

"I have no idea what the lot of you are on about, you are detracting from the case at hand."

BrotherStynier wrote:"I have no idea what the lot of you are on about, you are detracting from the case at hand."

Instead of EF said: I put Genestealer. I will not talk about that again.

lord of the ghosts wrote:

Genestealer wrote:@Deff Dread: You've said that before as well. You might want to get some sleep, mate.

It is undeniable that TLOG is using scummy logic. Whether this is just him being scummy, or him being a scummy genestealer is nowhere near as clear.

How about we lynch him and found out? (I love Imperial logic )

Hmmm.... Let's all kill the guy with the bolter!!
Vote:Emperors Faithful

Edit: [b/] to [/b]

Hmm, I question your scummy logic and you jump out with a retalitory vote against me. Without any basis for it. Scared? Feeling a bit threatened are you, Lord of Genestealers?

EF, watch out, you keep saying everything is scummy. People might be offended.

OOC: I have no other questions at the moment, as any I have thought up have been asked and answered, and we seem to need to post at least once a day in this...
Go useless filler post

the_ferrett wrote:EF, watch out, you keep saying everything is scummy. People might be offended.

Forgive me if I don't seem like I worry about hurting genestealers feelings. I call it like I see it, and IMO lord of the ghosts' logic is worth gak. What do you think of this character, who deems you to be 47% genestealer and says he's a Pubescent Marine?

If I thought all who accused me scummy, well I'd be insulting alot of people. Although, 47% is a fairly random number. I prefer 42.

42. I see what you did there.

I was accusing him of general scummy..ish...ness long before he voted for me. He failure of logic and all round hyperbole both made me sick and sparked my suspicion. Only after I voted for him and demanded that he talk did he vote back. And he hasn't given a what or a why since or before then.

Random? Yes.
Scummy? Yeah.
Genestealer? Maybe. He's not talking.

As I said, LotG is using increasingly scummy logic.

LotG, when someone votes for you, simply putting a retaliatory vote back is no use to the imperium, if you are indeed a normal citizen. As Thor told me last game, the objective of the imperial citizens is not to survive, but to find genestealers. Just because someone votes for you, doesn't make them a 'stealer. Voting back simply incriminates you more, which can't be good for the imperium (assuming you're just a normal citizen), can it?

Ergo, if you continue with this whole retaliation vote thing, you're most probably a 'stealer.
EDIT: Me no spell good.

lord of ghosts that is very scummy indeed
vote: lord of ghosts

Not to be rude or anything... but if we're waiting until 1-2 hours left, shouldn't we all be not voting? Or... wait what are we actually waiting for in terms of 'hours' (See OOC days)? Not that I don't appreciate the holding off of the metaphorical flames up the.... Nope that'd be a stupid metaphor to use as that term now means something else. Was going to go with a Salem metaphor.

If we don't vote now, we have nothing to go on to decide who to vote on at the end of the day.

But won't it just push the votes to a third almost which we'll disqualify, realise we're rushing it and all scramble to make a final choice which will be sub-par? Why don't we set a time when we can start the final run and when we get to essentially lock in with a side.

I will vote nearier the end of the day. Im watching now.

the_ferret: What are you trying to say? You want us to all vote (for someone) now? Rather than wait till closer to the deadline? I understand what you mean by the last minute rush to choose someone but I believe Lord Loss is right when he says we should stretch the discussion out a bit. (Of course, 11 pages on Day 1 is fairly stretched as it is. )

@Lord Loss: Voting now would be useful, noone is too close to the deadmark and I'd like to see where you stand. Who do you find to be the most suspicious so far?

((OOC We started on 5th Jan, it is a 2 week day phase, so we have ages to decide, right? Just want to check the first day is the same length as any other...)))

Dark Lord Seanron seems very suspicious right now... His defenses of his actions seem odd. "Blood-letting psycopath" rather than "alien", as if being an alien is not remarkable at all... to him.

Mekboy seems very keen to get people voting - is he a xenos trying to get people lynched by accident?

Is Lord-Loss a 'stealer trying to misdirect people away from himself? I doubt it, but it would be unwise to discount it. Emperor's Faithful now seems to be quite guided by Lord-Loss, after earlier disagreement... was all of that a ruse to make people think they are enemies, whilst in truth they are allies in their evil xenos plot?

Ferret's unusual voting pattern is worrying, to say the least, from what I can work out.

Gornall seems very logical and only says what he has to - is he a sly killer on the lookout for prey?

All of this has left me not knowing who to trust. Even from the rest of you, I am worried that I can't trust any of you yet.

As for when night comes - I dread to think who will get killed. Whoever it is, I worry that we will learn little at the first death, as the 'stealers may be wary of killing anyone who stands out as they are likely to get lynched anyway, saving themselves the bother...

The ferret, you want us all to vote, possibly to rush the day phase? Maybe because you have your assassination planned? Regardless Vote: The ferret

Fifty wrote:Mekboy seems very keen to get people voting - is he a xenos trying to get people lynched by accident?

Surely you do not advise that we simply wait for day to tick over into night, and let the genestealers pick us off one by one?

No, I think you are probably just trying to get people thinking... just an observation. It occurs to me to stop telling people how to avoid giving themselves away, however.

ginger_nid_dude wrote:The ferret, you want us all to vote, possibly to rush the day phase? Maybe because you have your assassination planned? Regardless Vote: The ferret

the_ferret hasn't actually said that he want's us all to vote now. (Indeed, right now HE is the one with most votes against him, so it's not the best thing for him to advise) He simply wishes to avoid a last minute rush to get a lynch (any lynch) if we delay until the deadline creeps up.

@Fifty: I understand what you're saying, but sooner or later you're going to have to pick some friends. Right now I am fairly certain that Lord Loss is decidely not a genestealer as his reasonable defense of both Drk_O AND the_ferret is very ungenestealer like. A genestealer would probably encourage, or at the least not act against a quick lynch. Lord Loss defended those who looked liek they were heading to a quick lynch on two seperate occasions, one would have been enough if he was a genestealer wanting a smokescreen, but a genestealer wouldn't go out of his way and put himself in the spotlight to protect two innocents (And I have already stated why I believe Drk_O and the_ferret far too unlikely to be genestealers).

I find DLS most suspicous at the moment. He seems not to care whether the first lynch is a citizen or a 'stealer. This is an important part of the game and the amount of discussion we get before someone is lynched or night-killed is important. A good 'stealer will cast doubt after a night kill, they will most likely target someone who has conflict with another innocent. That way they can make the innocent seem very suspicous. We should all watch out for this. If we have a doctor here, I urge you too protect someone who uses logic and fits the above description for 'stealer targets. While some people may make stupid mistakes, It doesnt mean there 'stealers.

Great. Now the genestealers are going to read this and target dumb people. (Help! ) Or they'll target you. *points at monitor*

Serious face: LOTG's voting pattern is very 'erratic' right now. I would call it downright suspicious, but this could just be the voting pattern of a very silly (and not at all helpful) Citizen. I'm not too sure about that though.

You must vote how you feel is right, of course.

What I find strange is that DLS knows (or at least suspects) that Drk_O was only joking around but is still dead set against him.

BrotherStynier wrote:You must vote how you feel is right, of course.

Feelings mean nothing in the Imperium.

I really dont know how to vote at the moment. Im suspicous of everyone really. And though Dark Lord Seanron is very suspicous, this could be the work of an over-excited citizen. The same goes for Drk_Oblit and The_Ferret.

BrotherStynier wrote:You must vote how you feel is right, of course.

Wrong, dont rely on hunches. Use evidence from previous discussions to help find 'stealers. Reading over the thread again can help.

If you act on fact presented to you, they affect your feelings on the matter, thus you'll still be doing what you feel to be correct.

I've read over this thread, so far any "Evidence" against anyone person would be rather lacking, so far the evidence points to:

-One of us not knowing when to stop running a joke into the ground.

-One of us appearing rather blood thirsty.

-One of us pulling percentages and theories about who is loyal and who is not out of their ass.

-Against me you've got my being not hostile towards everyone, my voting for Drk_O and saying that you need to trust you instincts and feelings on the first day.

-And then theres you, who has been suspiciously protective of certain individuals.