Well that's the thing though even with S7 they are still a hit and miss thing. I do agree that S7 might be over the top but they are so unreliable that it is kinda random to take them for points.
Deny the witch means that one round in the game you won't be doing anything.
If that passes.
Psychic tests means that in 2 games chances are 1 round of shooting will do absolutely nothing as well.
If that passes.
Average of 7 Dice means 3.5 hits, at S5 wounds on 3s generally, 3.33 wounds.
With a 3+ save, on average means 1.11 wounds go through.
Then there's the chance 2/3 chance of giving out
FNP(6+)
and then soul blaze and stuff.
If you were to be able to shoot all 6 turns, on average you'd cause
~5.00 wounds or less from the shooting itself, 0.333 wounds from soul blaze, 2-3 wounds from Warp Flame and 4
FNP +1.
Didn't put the math into calculating wounds if the unit had the
FNP from flickerfire, so the actual wounds are even lower.
^the above taken the failed psychic tests and DtW test in accout.
Compared to a Chaos marine squad, 95 points that's including a plasma gun.
let's say they never rapid fire.
24 Bolters and 6 Plasma over the entire game.
16 hits 8 wounds, 4 hits, 3.33 wounds.
6 wounds in total for the entire game excluding rapid fire.
So on average both squads shoot about 6-7 wounds in total, whilst Pink Horrors give out
FNP and are less survivable than a Marine squad, and the marine squad isn't even shooting at their full capacity.
By all means my math could be wrong since there's so many factors for calculating pink horrors that it's really hard to determine the average since there are so many factors affecting it with the
FNP give away being the largest.
Automatically Appended Next Post: oh, and if they have any psykers you lose another round of shootin g or lose a bunch of targets that you can shoot at.
and if that psyker is Eldrad you might as well charge them into something and you'll probably do more damage there instead of killing yourself...
Automatically Appended Next Post: by all means with a herald they are pretty good if they get to shoot.
But then they become pretty expensive and is still pretty unreliable.
But hey Chaos is fickle!