Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you:
No adverts like this in the forums anymore.
Times and dates in your local timezone.
Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance.
Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely.
Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net.
If you are already a member then feel free to login now.
A reaver with caltrops will inflict D6 S6 rending HoW attacks, correct? So that means that a squad of 9 Reavers can inflict 9D6 S6 rending attacks, right?
Old caltrops were 1 caltrop per 3 reavers and cost 20 points. Expect them to stay 1 per 3, or even 1 per unit and to be 20 or more points(more than another reaver)
So it might be 9 reavers, with 3 caltrops, would be 6 str4 hits and 3d6 str6 hits.
it might be less, we dont know.
Dark Mechanicus and Renegade Iron Hand Dakka Blog
My Dark Mechanicus P&M Blog. Mostly Modeling as I paint very slowly. Lots of kitbashed conversions of marines and a few guard to make up a renegade Iron Hand chapter and Dark Mechanicus Allies. Bionics++
9 reavers will kill 9 tac marines if the tac marines do not have any upgrades(ie they cost 40% less) and do not shoot the reavers at all before they assault. Given reavers are not making a first turn assault this is of course unlikely.
9 Tac marines that are plain (something you will probably never see on a table top) would still be able to get up to 3 rounds of shooting versus reavers depending on assault distance rolled,
ie 1 round moving back shooting, 1 round moving back shooting, 1 round moving up rapid firing, then overwatch.
rapid fire for total of 4 casualties, overwatch for 1.5 casualties (will be nice and round to 1) so reavers now have 4 models from starting 5.
lets say all three caltrops survived, so average is rounded up to 2 rends, 1 str4 hit and 8 str6 hits, which is 2 casualties plus average 5.5 saves to be made, will round up to 6 saves to be made, average is 2 fails so 4 marine casualties.
we now have assault between 4 str3 WS4 T3 4+ save models and 5 str4 WS4 T4 3+ save models
averages show marines winning.
thats 9 unupgraded tac marines versus 9 upgraded reavers, or 136 pts versus 204 pts of dark eldar.
FWIW if the marine player had 1 less round of baiting the reavers, the results would be assault with 5 reavers versus 5 tac marines, still favoring the tac marines.
2014/10/01 16:56:19
Subject: Re:Dark Eldar rumors - pics and video page1
mercury14 wrote: It's highly doubtful that all Reavers could get Caltrops and I doubt you'd want to spend the points for it. If it's 1/3 like before Your 9-Reaver unit would have up to 3 caltrops and then 6 bladevanes. So 3D6+6 S4 rending auto-hits on I10.
- 17 hits on average and three of them rend. So three dead MEQ or about one dead Termi from just the rending
- Plus another half-dozen or so regular wounds = two more dead MEQ or another dead termi
Most of a Tac Marine squad would be dead on I10 before they could blink so I'm not sure why people are saying Reavers lose to Tacs. The Reavers can also kill stuff before assaulting with their shooting too.
Now calculate the cost of these Reavers vs. a tac squad
Well we don't know the cost of Caltrops but if they stay 20pts, it'd be something like 220pts for a 10 man squad (maximum size in last codex) with 3 Caltrops
Maximum size was nine, so 60+(16x9)= 204.
It was 10, there was just little point in taking the 10th man.
Also there is some huge dreaming in this thread about these HoW attacks. You need to make initial b2b contact, your probably going to hide your caltrops from shooting thus making them pointless. Otherwise my 5 man combat squads that usually run with a flamer or combi flamer will slow roast the caltrops on the way in with wall of flame.
I can see reavers as small maelstrom grabbers with a suicide heatlance but trying to make anything work as an assault unit in 7th is difficult before you even start considering single wound cheap models. Thats why I don't understand the surprise by most posters that wyches and hellions also are lack luster. If wyches were 7ppm they would still be a wasted slot option, and in order to make them killy in assault they would need a MASSIVE overhaul which would make them more expensive and thus still a dead option. 7th killed those units and I don't care how much dreaming people do, nothing in this release was going to make naked T3 assaulter good lol.
Automatically Appended Next Post:
Spoiler:
blaktoof wrote: 9 reavers will kill 9 tac marines if the tac marines do not have any upgrades(ie they cost 40% less) and do not shoot the reavers at all before they assault. Given reavers are not making a first turn assault this is of course unlikely.
9 Tac marines that are plain (something you will probably never see on a table top) would still be able to get up to 3 rounds of shooting versus reavers depending on assault distance rolled,
ie 1 round moving back shooting, 1 round moving back shooting, 1 round moving up rapid firing, then overwatch.
rapid fire for total of 4 casualties, overwatch for 1.5 casualties (will be nice and round to 1) so reavers now have 4 models from starting 5.
lets say all three caltrops survived, so average is rounded up to 2 rends, 1 str4 hit and 8 str6 hits, which is 2 casualties plus average 5.5 saves to be made, will round up to 6 saves to be made, average is 2 fails so 4 marine casualties.
we now have assault between 4 str3 WS4 T3 4+ save models and 5 str4 WS4 T4 3+ save models
averages show marines winning.
thats 9 unupgraded tac marines versus 9 upgraded reavers, or 136 pts versus 204 pts of dark eldar.
FWIW if the marine player had 1 less round of baiting the reavers, the results would be assault with 5 reavers versus 5 tac marines, still favoring the tac marines.
These arguments are so futile. Reavers are eldar jetbikes and can be anywhere in a turn so more then likely a tac squad will get one turn plus overwatch. better question is whether you can jink from overwatch? Either way I think the FA slot will now have much better options. Heck even an empty venom is better point for point IMO. People arguing in favor of the HoW have clearly never tried to set up a charge with that rule in mind let alone relied on it. It really hard making b2b contact with each model on the initial charge especially with those awful jetbike bases.
This message was edited 3 times. Last update was at 2014/10/01 17:03:11
I agree the above arguement is futile more or less, however ultimately the point is you are looking at -usually- at least1 round of shooting plus 1 round of overwatch before you try to get a charge off- which we both agree on.
I think we also see how silly it is to assume a 9 man tac squad as you pointed out two 5 man squads with flamer and combi flamer in each. Which ultimately results in more dead reavers than the example I posted.
the end result is HoW on reavers being improved, is no where nearly as competitive as bladevaning was before.
This message was edited 3 times. Last update was at 2014/10/01 17:07:01
2014/10/01 17:15:01
Subject: Re:Dark Eldar rumors - pics and video page1
mercury14 wrote: Blak, that scenario is pretty meaningless since combats like that don't occur in isolation but in the context of a much larger battle.
then don't post nonsense like:
They're about the same given upgrades.
But it also doesn't matter because 9 reavers with caltrops will still beat 9 Tac Marines
.
if you don't want to talk about things in isolation.
2014/10/01 17:26:08
Subject: Re:Dark Eldar rumors - pics and video page1
You were referring to two isolated units that end up in CC together without one of the units being touched prior to the assault, which is enacting a non-existent isolated scenario...
2014/10/01 17:30:22
Subject: Re:Dark Eldar rumors - pics and video page1
mercury14 wrote: I was referring to those units in a CC together, not enacting a non-existent scenario where they're dueling from across the map....
To be fair you were in fact playing that same futile game, just in a much less thorough way. Units never just appear in CC.
I think we can agree Reavers are different and a bit worse, but also cheaper so it is more of a sideways movement in power. Now there is some reason for AT weapons on them at least. I think it is the other options in FA that invalidate them competitively. Still ace models at least
blaktoof wrote: You were referring to two isolated units that end up in CC together without one of the units being touched prior to the assault, which is enacting a non-existent isolated scenario...
You never see untouched units at like the top of turn two?
2014/10/01 17:34:53
Subject: Re:Dark Eldar rumors - pics and video page1
Wait, since DTs are going to be FA choices now, it's possible to stick a lone Archon in a Venom? Not that it makes much sense, but it's possible, right?
Drukhari - 4.7k
Space Marines - 3.1k
Chaos Space Marines - 2.9k
Harlequins - 0.9k
2014/10/01 17:37:23
Subject: Re:Dark Eldar rumors - pics and video page1
SarisKhan wrote: Wait, since DTs are going to be FA choices now, it's possible to stick a lone Archon in a Venom? Not that it makes much sense, but it's possible, right?
DE ded transports are FA? Is this confirmed?
2014/10/01 17:42:11
Subject: Re:Dark Eldar rumors - pics and video page1
The new Archons pose is too static and awkward for my liking. The crafting and detailing is excellent, I'm not going to disagree on that point - but I certainly don't like the pose. Who stands bolt upright with their arms crossed so high? It's an entirely unnatural, awkward position that doesn't sit with the arrogant and confident (and therefore seeming relaxed pose) I have grown to expect from the artwork and previous Archon model - which I very much like.
I feel the same way about the new Haemonculus model - rather than the creepy versions previously provided, we now have this emo-esque, big footed drip of a character. Once again very detailed but lacking the sinister aspect seen previously in the models. I hate to say it, all I can see is this guy from spiderman 3
This aside, that new bomber looks beautiful and the bloodbrides look dynamic, attractive yet sinister - they hit the nail on the head there.
I only hope that the codex is good - as after tearing out both the Duke and the Lady (the two characters my army was based around) I'm frankly disinterested at the moment.
Thousand Sons: 3850pts / Space Marines Deathwatch 5000pts / Dark Eldar Webway Corsairs 2000pts / Scrapheap Challenged Orks 1500pts / Black Death 1500pts
Someone on The Dark City has got their codex early and is answering questions. This is true, he took pictures and sent them to the mod to prove he has them.
I'm afraid to say most of the rumors were true, no buffs for Wyches and No Sky Boards or Bikes for our Archons. Yes, that means the hundreds of lovingly converting Barons are downgraded to Helliarchs :(
But not one to dwell on the sad side, he has found a hidden gem among the heep and i thought it might brighten your day somewhat. Grotesques now don't explode when left alone, they have a very similar statline but come with Rampage and a Flesh Gauntlet + Close Combat Weapon base! Yikes! The Flesh Gauntlet is S user Ap - Poison 4+ Lethal Dose, which causes instant death on the to wound roll of a 6. So 3 attacks base, +1 for 2 CC weapons + 1 for charging +D3 for Rampage + 1 for Rage means in the optimum situation each Grot is throwing out 9(!) Str 6 (Furious Charge) attacks EACH.
Same about the models though, although i could do with a new Talos and the spare parts + Rat Ogres could go a long way...
2014/10/01 17:50:20
Subject: Re:Dark Eldar rumors - pics and video page1
PhillyT wrote: Come on, it is a classic play off stylized Eastern Martial Arts poses and stances. You guys are fuddy duddys.
A martial arts pose would have been good - instead we got a ballerina
Thousand Sons: 3850pts / Space Marines Deathwatch 5000pts / Dark Eldar Webway Corsairs 2000pts / Scrapheap Challenged Orks 1500pts / Black Death 1500pts
A member of the Dark City has the codex and has PM'd the mods with proof to confirm.
Talos are 1-3 in a unit.
Cronos the same but cant mix with Talos.
Kabalites are the same allthough PGL is as rumoured soulblight (no way of getting defensive grenades). 8 points and may take a raider even though a unit is 10+.
Razorwing is 130 points, may only take nightshields (which gives steath) and is a fast choice (not heavy). Its not a vector dancer :-( Dark Lances cost 5 more points each than a disintegrators.
Q: Can a unit champion for jetbikes get or take a power axe? any Power weapon?
A: Only power swords and Agonisers which is AP 3, poison (4+)
Q: What would the total cost of 5 scourges with 4 haywire guns cost?
A: 120
Q: Wyches... 2 attacks base or 1? (extra hand weapon and charge = 4 attacks each?)
A: 1 attack
Q: Do Kaivex (Exarch) Powers still exist?
A: No
Q: Did Ravagers lose Aerial Assault? Still AV11?
A: Yes and still AV11
Q: Is the Haemonculus (the small/cheap one 1 - 3 choice) gone and fully replaced by the ancient?
A: He is gone. Ancient is in.
Q: Are there any formations (like the Tyranid Dataslates or the Apoc book formations) in the book?
A: 1 formation
Q: Did the Lhamean keep her "give 2+ poison to archon" special rule?
A: No
Q: Did Talos get any new movement rules?
A: No
Q: Grotesques, same stats, points and options? Still blow up if not joined by an independent character?
A: Grotesques are the new hit, I think. Same stats but.... they do not blow up and they got Flesh gauntlets + ccw and Rampage. Nice!! Flesh Gauntlets: S as user, AP-, Lethal Dose, poison (4+).
Lethal Dose: 6 to wound gives ID.
Q: Are scourge rumours true, squads of 5 can take 4 heavy weapons?
A: Yes
Q: 6 fast attack slots?
A: In the "Realspace Raiders Detachment" can you get 6 fast choices, yes. Giving 5+ cover save to troops and 6+ cover save too all others units in the detachment int the first turn AND any turn with night fighting.
Q: can other units enter via webway portal once deepstriked in?
A: any unit the Archon/succubus/heamon that has it have joint and their transport. Thats DS without scattering.
Q: does webwat portal use same small blast template as before(really hope my webway portals get used!)
A: No blast.
Q: Transport capacity of vehicles the same?
A: Yes
Q: Can any if the HQs take a bike or sky board?
A: No and no
Q: are there still trueborn in there and can they still take the same weapons they did in the old dex
A: Yes and Yes.
Q: are mandrakes better?
A: Much better, stealth, shrouded and baleblast from start. Baleblast: assault 2, St 4. AP4, soulblaze
Q: what got nerfed in terms of units
A: Wyches are dead no buffs, no haywire, Dodge only in Fight subphase. Incubi cant get grenades.
Q: can venoms still take double splinter cannons?
A: Yes but can only get Grisly trophies and chain snares.... no shields. SUCKS!!
Q: what defenses did our vehicles get ?, with the removal of Flickerfields to everything other than venoms.
A: Night shields give stealth and the new detachment gives cover in the first turn.
Q: how much is a shadowfield now?/ who can take them
A: 4+ inv, 40 points, only archon
Q: What do WWP's do now? and how many points?
A: gives DS without scatter, 35 points, archon/succubus/ heamon can take it.
Q: Can the flyers take flickerfields?
A: No
Q: Do wyches have any chance to survive overwatch and raider explosion? or nothing has changed?
A: No change
Q: Which units have access to Haywire weapons?
A: only wych champion, succubus, archon
Q: Are Harlequins still in the book?
A: Only in fluff, no entry
Q: wait are the shadowfields now a 4+ invul?
A: No, sorry, I mixed it up. Clonefield is 4+ inv. Shadowfield is allmost the same. It works until the end of the phase inwhich you fail the 2+ inv.
This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2014/10/01 18:12:46
I like the shadowfield shorting out at the end of the phase instead of immediately.
Also the dude on Dark City claims that there were no changes to the trueborn weapons options, meaning (I assume) that they can still take shardcarbines.
5000
Who knows?
2014/10/01 18:14:23
Subject: Re:Dark Eldar rumors - pics and video page1
Looks like they have gone for the flesh cult as the primary element of the Dark Eldar and screw the rest
well looks like final nail in the coffin for Wyches and Incubi worse
I AM A MARINE PLAYER
"Unimaginably ancient xenos artefact somewhere on the planet, hive fleet poised above our heads, hidden 'stealer broods making an early start....and now a bloody Chaos cult crawling out of the woodwork just in case we were bored. Welcome to my world, Ciaphas."
Inquisitor Amberley Vail, Ordo Xenos
"I will admit that some Primachs like Russ or Horus could have a chance against an unarmed 12 year old novice but, a full Battle Sister??!! One to one? In close combat? Perhaps three Primarchs fighting together... but just one Primarch?" da001
Q: Sorry for the barrage but this one's kinda huge.. are saying warriors went to min size 10? If so do they still unlock venoms?
A: 5 is the minimum size but you can buy a raider to a unit that is 10+ big.
Automatically Appended Next Post: And more still:
Q: Can an Archon have any AP2 weapon at all?
A: Not in Melee
Q: Which models can have a Venomblade?
A: Acothyst
Q: Are combat drugs an item that HQ's can buy from a list (like a Space marine captain can buy an Auspex), or is it directly bought within the entry? Can an Archon still buy it?
A: No drugs for archon
Q: Are Venoms and Raiders Fast Attacks as well as Dedicated Transports?
A: yes
This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2014/10/01 18:25:33
2014/10/01 18:28:54
Subject: Re:Dark Eldar rumors - pics and video page1
3A
+ 1 charging
+1 two CCWs + D3 if they're outnumbered and can rampage (fairly likely)
And they ID on a 6.
S5 and poison (4+) means that against a T3/T4 target they get to use their strength and re-roll failed wounds, so they almost always wound T4 and get lots of ID chances due to the rerolls.
For 35 points.
And they no longer need a babysitter.
Oh and they can get furious charge to make them S6 on turn 4.
Six mistakes mankind keeps making century after century: Believing that personal gain is made by crushing others; Worrying about things that cannot be changed or corrected; Insisting that a thing is impossible because we cannot accomplish it; Refusing to set aside trivial preferences; Neglecting development and refinement of the mind; Attempting to compel others to believe and live as we do
Q: How have Incubi been changed?
A: No, but no way of getting assault grenades
Q:Are their Klaives now unwieldy?
A: No
Q: And what bonusses does the Klaivex now give?
A: He has Rampage
Q: What does soulblight do?
A: Sorry, soulfright:
At the end of shooting phase, a unit that has been hit by a weapon with that rule must make a Ld test. units takes wound with no armour or cover save for each point the test is failed by. Doesn't Work on Fearless and ATSKNF.
Both PGL and TGL has that.
PGL: range 18", S 1, AP-, assault 1, blast, soulfright
TGL: range 24", S 1, AP-, assault 1, blast, soulfright
Q: Does Urien still offer a S6 upgrade to Grots?
A: No.