Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

sorry but what do I need to explain?
if its my voting
Its because I dont have time to read everythink so just read some bits and if there any I find that I also foun I said
From now on though it should be more detailed

BishopGore wrote:Unvote: Arheiner

I retain suspicion of Arheiner, but I just don't have enough to go on to make it stick. I have strong suspicions of 2 of the people who were still voting for Shas'O at end of Day Phase 1, both Rusty and Arheiner seem likely candidates to be Dark Kin, not sure about Scarper.

Rusty's vote for Lord-Loss seems more like a tactic than an actual vote. But that might just be because I feel both are contenders for Dark Kin.

Overall I'm back to my confusion, as I am sure the Dark Kin wanted.

How much bolder do you want it? Maybe pay more attention

Vulkan_He'stan wrote:sorry but what do I need to explain?
if its my voting
Its because I dont have time to read everythink so just read some bits and if there any I find that I also foun I said
From now on though it should be more detailed

You really do sound exactly like Shas'O...

We're asking you to sit down, read through what has been going on and just make some constructive statements, talk about who you find guilty, get involved. It will stop people feeling so uneasy about the things you come out with.

It really doesn't take up all that much time to think or read or, Khaine forbid, spellcheck.

DON'T GO THERE EF!!

Bishop, my bad. I missed your post directly below the tally ><

Lord-Loss wrote:DON'T GO THERE EF!!

Haha, I very firmly took off my Grammar Nazi hat when I saw Shas'O was in the game and it's really got to stay off or I'll go completely wacko

No worries ferrett, I should probably put votes and unvotes at the ends of my posts rather than the beginning where they blend in with the top bar. Something else for me to work on!

But yes, 3/2. Its all down to the silent masses.

Problem is, with Vulkan sitting there, a pretty sure thing for a lynch in a week's time, I can't see why any of the silent players would really do anything. If they're Dark Kin, they can sit back and laugh about it, if they're worried about drawing attention to themselves, they also might stay silent or noncommital.

Overall I think this Day Phase may drag on for the next few days and just end in a welter of gore with us no closer to finding who is doing all this killing.

What happens if 2 or more people are drawing for the lynch when the Day Phase ends? Do 2 people die? Does nobody die? If it's the latter, maybe those of us who aren't Dark Kin should set it up so there's 2 people who are tied, that may force the hand of a Dark Kin?

Again, this is an idea I have had, please tell me if it's unworkable or ridiculous, don't start calling me scummy

From the way its worded in a previous game, there are mechanics set up to decide.... possibly the last one to get a vote?

(Hey all! Sorry I've been quiet for a bit, some pretty heavy IRL stuff going on. Hopefully it's sorted now!)

Personally, I'm not sure about Vulkan anymore. It may just be nerves after inadvertently lynching someone for similar behaviour who turned out to be innocent, but I'm starting to feel like as a younger player, it's quite possible that he just isn't bothering to read the whole thread and is voting with the flow. Annoying behaviour, or scummy behaviour? If there are no better candidates, I can't see it being the end of the world if he does get a lynch.

The Lord Loss thing - you've made a few suspicious moves, and you've tried hard to explain them. The match up with EF seems to make sense, and defending eachother, whilst obviously a neccessity, doesn't really ditch the whole 'DE team thing'. I am a little suspicious the Rusty seems to be among the loudest calling for his lynching - maybe distracting attention from his position as a (fellow!) Shas'o killer? I'm holdingmy vote back for now, but I'd love to hear some more from Arheiner

I also apologise for being quiet, had a fair few internals recently (pretty much assessments) but tomorrow is the last day of term, so will get a few weeks after that to contribute more

I really don't think we've accomplished very much today, it really has just been waiting for Vulkan and i've had enough, we need to start questioning some others.

As for me I don't really have that much to say, I've got a two week break from my course starting today. But, I've got an 80 page assignment to do in that time due the week after I go back so generally the amount of time I put into this will be unchanged
Then a few others due after that I should really look up the due dates for >_>

None of us can be sure that Vulkan isn't Dark Kin, but it really does look like he's a quieter Shas'O, bored of the game because he doesn't have an interesting role. I feel like I'm turning into a stuck gramaphone record, but I feel lynching Vulkan would be a mistake.

That being said, there's so little to grab onto at the moment, because the Dark Kin have been very sneaky so far.

I'm still looking at Lord-Loss and Arheiner, very possibly Rusty too, as Dark Kin, but I don't think all 3 of them could be, at least one must be on our side. There's no way my senses are that finely attuned!

LL is the main one we need to look at other than Vulkan ATM, so we need to get on with him while Vulkan pretends to be here some more.

Because that doesn't sound at all people manipulating at all....

BishopGore wrote:None of us can be sure that Vulkan isn't Dark Kin, but it really does look like he's a quieter Shas'O, bored of the game because he doesn't have an interesting role. I feel like I'm turning into a stuck gramaphone record, but I feel lynching Vulkan would be a mistake.

Actually, that's a good point.
I think you said something earlier (Day 1) about Shas'o as well.

I'm still looking at Lord-Loss and Arheiner, very possibly Rusty too, as Dark Kin, but I don't think all 3 of them could be, at least one must be on our side. There's no way my senses are that finely attuned!

My Bishop-Sense is tingling!

Emperors Faithful wrote:Actually, that's a good point.
I think you said something earlier (Day 1) about Shas'o as well.

I did, I turned out to be right, but that doesn't mean I am this time. But still, if something has a great deal of opportunity for fun you usually don't put it off. Unless he's so very clever that he's using Shas'O as a mask...

Emperors Faithful wrote:My Bishop-Sense is tingling!

The Holy Smackdown is coming!

Can we hear from those that are voting for Vulkan why they are still voting for him? I'm especially interested in Arheiner and EF as Arheiner is telling us we need to look at LL and EF has been constantly worrying that Vulkan will be killed (even though he expressed regret in lynching Shas'o for the same reason that ferret was lynched last game). To me it looks an awful lot like two people trying to avoid suspicion while protecting LL (by keeping votes on Vulkan).

the_ferrett wrote:Because that doesn't sound at all people manipulating at all....

I was going to lambast you for random, poorly formatted accusations, but I'm actually rather critical of Arheiner at the moment (mostly due to him and all the other quiet people making a filler post that added absolutely nothing to the conversation).

Rusty, why am I voting for Vulkan? Because I had that nice big conversation about his guilt a few pages back. The logic of that arguament stick with me still.

I honestly don't know what to say at the moment. Apart from Bishop (for the idea on Day one of lynching all the exprienced players) and Rusty (accused me of a massive change in my play style while he has obviously changed from the back seat quite typeish to an agressive player, which is the opposite of what I've done) I can't see many suspicous people. I don't know who we should lynch today... It's usually not pro-town to not lynch someone... and Vulkan has been pretty suspicous during day one and he hasn't explained himself even though he said he would do it several days ago... I'm still not sure, he seems fairly younge and It might be a repeat of Shas, which we don't want.

(OOC: I havn't had as much time as I did during Day One really, so you can blame part of my change on that.. I don't like using RL stuff as an excuse but it's true...)

back again putting my brand new computer together
yey Video gaming PC

I think today has had too many silent people thats why
Vote: no lynch

I like that you're only suspicious of the people voting for you Lord-Loss Do you think only Dark Kin could possibly vote for you? I joke, apologies.

Honestly I see where Vulkan is coming from with the no lynch vote, but it's just going to make Day 3 an even quieter version of today, and it has been very quiet. I honestly think someone has to die today if we're going to get anywhere.

I doubt I'll survive the night after a lynch today, as I have been a bit all over the place with my voting and comments and will cast plenty of odd shadows in the Warp with my passing, but maybe tonight we can at least take down a Dark Kin. 30% chance if a D10 were to be rolled (no, I'm NOT suggesting we do this, I'm talking statistics).

I want some more from Arheiner, Avantgarde and Scarper. They are moving up to my midly suspicous list with there silence..

the_ferrett wrote:Rusty, why am I voting for Vulkan? Because I had that nice big conversation about his guilt a few pages back. The logic of that arguament stick with me still.

You mean the conversation where Arheiner needled you into voting with him? "If you're not blind you can tell." He manipulated you, rather artfully I might add. He's now number three on my Dark Kin Dream Team (LL/EF/Arheiner).

Lord-Loss wrote:I honestly don't know what to say at the moment. Apart from Bishop (for the idea on Day one of lynching all the exprienced players) and Rusty (accused me of a massive change in my play style while he has obviously changed from the back seat quite typeish to an agressive player, which is the opposite of what I've done) I can't see many suspicous people. I don't know who we should lynch today... It's usually not pro-town to not lynch someone... and Vulkan has been pretty suspicous during day one and he hasn't explained himself even though he said he would do it several days ago... I'm still not sure, he seems fairly younge and It might be a repeat of Shas, which we don't want.

Of course my play style changed. I was a genestealer last game. Did your playstyle change because you're the scum now? I completely agree that was shouldn't repeat shas'o's death.

Lord-Loss wrote:(OOC: I havn't had as much time as I did during Day One really, so you can blame part of my change on that.. I don't like using RL stuff as an excuse but it's true...)

You've still managed to reply rather sharpishly to all of my accusations.

Vulkan_He'stan wrote:back again putting my brand new computer together
yey Video gaming PC

I think today has had too many silent people thats why
Vote: no lynch

Funny irony is funny.

Lord-Loss wrote:I want some more from Arheiner, Avantgarde and Scarper. They are moving up to my midly suspicous list with there silence..

As soon as BishopGore questions your suspicious list you add more... A bit eager to please, ehh?

Adding message to Vulkan-
Why don't you give us your thoughts on LL?

(I'm rather interested in his actions, as lynching LL saves Vulkan for at least a day)

I'm slighltly suspicious of lord loss
no evidence just small things

Rusty... I was reffering to you during Day One on This game not any other game.

You've still managed to reply rather sharpishly to all of my accusations.

When I had time I tried too. They were pretty rushed really...

Vulkan why are you suspicous of me with if there is no evidence, you say.