Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

Saddle up potna'

I would say to go with the saddle, but only if you're going to remove the raised front area (around the horn, etc). I think it might get uncomfortable for you, otherwise.
If you go with that tractor seat... PLEASE, tell me you'd be refinishing it. Your butt would be HURTING after a couple hours on that metal monstrosity.

Eric

Definitely whichever is more comfortable. The seat is definitely somewhere where functionality outweighs looks, especially since you're planning on riding it to places hours away. Take care of your ass!

My vote goes for the saddle, definitely! But I'd have to give way to functionality, I suppose. Is there a way you can rig the saddle to it so you can switch the seats out?

I like both , exactly as they are , without any more custom works , paint , nada.

Let your ass decide after an hours ride !

Tractor seat. Proppa Orky.

The tractor seat will kill you after 30-45 minutes.
The saddle might not be much nicer.

I like the look of the tractor seat significantly more though.

Might I suggest tat you add some springs to under the seat before mounting it, that might make for a more comfortable ride.

There is one more thing I thought of... You have some electrical gubbins under the seat. "The tractor seat has some holes in it." If your a serious rider then you will probably ride in the rain a few times (weather change after you start etc.) That being said if ya go with the tractor seat make sure you weather proof the electrical gubbins.

Tracktor seat iz mor orky

I think the saddle looks more aesthetically pleasing though my main concern with either choice is comfort.

SADDLE!

The saddle, definitely. Had I only seen the Deere I would have thought it looked good, but having seen that saddle on the bike I think it looks better by far.

Problem with saddles is they are not made to sit in with your legs as forward as they will be based on where your pegs/controls are. The pommel on that saddle may get in the way/cause some discomfort when riding.

You can get the tractor seat upholstered and cushioned.

Jake (who rides bikes and horses)

WOW...I'm torn really. Although I think I may have to agree with Jake here. As much as I like the concept of the saddle, especially that it matches your army. But I'd think going with the tractor seat as long as you pad/upholster it, would probably be better.

(Thanks Jake for the insight on saddles)

 CptJake wrote:
Problem with saddles is they are not made to sit in with your legs as forward as they will be based on where your pegs/controls are. The pommel on that saddle may get in the way/cause some discomfort when riding.

How difficult would it be to alter the saddle into a more suitable/comfortable shape?
If it's still a possibility I'd say go for it.

 CptJake wrote:
Problem with saddles is they are not made to sit in with your legs as forward as they will be based on where your pegs/controls are. The pommel on that saddle may get in the way/cause some discomfort when riding.

You can get the tractor seat upholstered and cushioned.

Jake (who rides bikes and horses)

The reason the tractor seat looks good is because of the holes, etc. Upholstering it would make it look like a normal motorcycle seat imo.

Unless you can get it upholstered with the holes in it.

rigeld2 wrote:

 CptJake wrote:
Problem with saddles is they are not made to sit in with your legs as forward as they will be based on where your pegs/controls are. The pommel on that saddle may get in the way/cause some discomfort when riding.

You can get the tractor seat upholstered and cushioned.

Jake (who rides bikes and horses)

The reason the tractor seat looks good is because of the holes, etc. Upholstering it would make it look like a normal motorcycle seat imo.

Unless you can get it upholstered with the holes in it.

you very well could by a custom shop i would imagine.

The saddle looks better is my take, as far as functionally, I have no idea. If you can make the saddle work, by modifying it to be more appropriate while retaining its aesthetic (as Xendarc said), that would be the route I would take!

Saddle, your ass will thank you later!

I'm goiong to say saddle but with the caveat that you do a butt test on both first. Mount them to a chair and pop a squat for 30-45 mins

optimusprime14 wrote:
I'm goiong to say saddle but with the caveat that you do a butt test on both first. Mount them to a chair and pop a squat for 30-45 mins

You would have to build a frame to hold them at the angle you will be on the bike, and place something where the foot controls/pegs will be. Mounting it on a chair won't cut it.

You could have a custom shop upholster the tractor seat and maintain the holes, I've seen it done. I would also consider a spring suspension for the seat.

The tractor seat just seems to fit the bike better- IMHO a saddle would look out of place on an Orky bike.

 Sinful Hero wrote:
The tractor seat just seems to fit the bike better- IMHO a saddle would look out of place on an Orky bike.

Agreed.

 KingCracker wrote:

 Sinful Hero wrote:
The tractor seat just seems to fit the bike better- IMHO a saddle would look out of place on an Orky bike.

Agreed.

Agreed too...

can you put some springy spring underneath the tractor seat? Not only for comfort, but I'd say it'll aesthetically add some orkiness to the whole thing.

Just saw this after doing a quick 'ork warbike' search

I thought it could be relevant/useful.

Orcs/Orks don't do saddles. Just grab the boar and hang on.

Use a lawn chair. Next choice is the saddle.

 CptJake wrote:

optimusprime14 wrote:
I'm goiong to say saddle but with the caveat that you do a butt test on both first. Mount them to a chair and pop a squat for 30-45 mins

You would have to build a frame to hold them at the angle you will be on the bike, and place something where the foot controls/pegs will be. Mounting it on a chair won't cut it.

You could have a custom shop upholster the tractor seat and maintain the holes, I've seen it done. I would also consider a spring suspension for the seat.

Oh I'm aware of that, it was more just a quick test to see how long you last in either.

As a fellow rider I worry that the tractor seat would just cause some major butt-numbness.

Utterly, utterly crazy. I LOVE IT!

 cormadepanda wrote:
Use a lawn chair. Next choice is the saddle.

perfect.

Use "quick change " bolts with "R" clips to secure the seat.
Have a big ass comfy leather one for long rides and the tractor seat for when you need to be too cool for sckool !