Squigs n Gretchens - WH40K Mafia Game - Game Over - Gretchin Win!? Vindicare Unlucky

Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you:

No adverts like this in the forums anymore.
Times and dates in your local timezone.
Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance.
Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely.
Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net.

If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

**VictorVonTzeentch**

I dont know Dark_O you posted that vote in pink, thats kinda suspicious. On the other hand, its kinda suspicious that I haven't voted for Ferret vet. So take that as you will.

**VictorVonTzeentch**

Obviously it means we are working together to kill all of you. Dan, there went our plan.

**VictorVonTzeentch**

Damn.

This is what I get for waking up at 8.

**Thor665**

Waking up at 8am on May 6th? ouch.

@Drk_O - what was I trying to avoid, and why are you not pressuring me about it?

If Rabtorium is town than that Krellums guy probably is too. It's a weaker read than the Rabotrium one though. I do think our votes would be far more useful off that wagon than on it.

**RiTides**

Thor665 wrote:Congratulations, you have successfully deduced that I am good at the game - if you're town you should probably not want me dead because I am on your side.

Note: you said this kind of thing last game, and you were scum. I.e., if you're scum, I think you're the biggest thread. However...

Thor665 wrote:If you're going with the ol' "Thor is too good to be trusted" at *least* give me a few days. If I'm really town than scum should be scared of me and kill me for you, and if I'm scum than I'll still be alive and then you can press the case with the ol' 'Why is Thor still alive case'.

I am going to hold you to this. If you're still alive on day 3, don't expect me to be convinced that you're not scum. This is a fair warning...

I am not sure who to vote for at the moment, but I am not going to unvote either since Thor thinks we should be lynching somebody

**RiTides**

Remove "thread". Insert "threat". The above makes so much more sense...

**BishopGore**

Fair enough Thor... for someone who usually speaks out for people giving long lists of reasons in case they die, that seems like an odd thing to say. I'll assume you are playing some cards close to your chest right now.

**Rabtorian**

I need to think about this. Unvote: Krellnus

**Mordoskul**

Striving to get a lynch, and possibly kill one of the scum,

Vote: Rabtorian

**Drk_Oblitr8r**

BrotherStynier wrote:I dont know Dark_O you posted that vote in pink, thats kinda suspicious. On the other hand, its kinda suspicious that I haven't voted for Ferret vet. So take that as you will.

It wasn't in pink, it was in Violet

My voting in Violet also sprang from this

n0t_u wrote:
Votes
1. It can be whatever colour or underlined if you feel the need, but it must be bold to count.

Drk_Oblitr8r wrote:Vote: Krellnus (all my votes will be this way, seeing as it's allowed P: )

Note that the vote is also in Italics, underlined and in size 24 font

Thor665 wrote:@Drk_O - what was I trying to avoid, and why are you not pressuring me about it?

Well, this.

BishopGore wrote:We probably need to start looking for people who are acting out of character.

9 mins 32 seconds later.

Thor665 wrote:Vote: Drk_O

Never a bad vote.

It seems much more than a coincidence to me, but I'm going to hold off voting for the moment.

**Drk_Oblitr8r**

@BrotherStynier

It looks pink in bold, for some reason.

**Thor665**

Mordoskul wrote:Striving to get a lynch, and possibly kill one of the scum,

Vote: Rabtorian

Why do you think Rabtorium is scum?

Drk_Oblitr8r wrote:
Thor665 wrote:@Drk_O - what was I trying to avoid, and why are you not pressuring me about it?

Well, this.

BishopGore wrote:We probably need to start looking for people who are acting out of character.

9 mins 32 seconds later.

Thor665 wrote:Vote: Drk_O

Never a bad vote.

It seems much more than a coincidence to me, but I'm going to hold off voting for the moment.

Are you saying me voting you is 'out of character' or are you saying that me voting you is 'in character'. I don't get your angle.

**Mordoskul**

I don't necessarily think he's scum, but better to narrow down the list rather than a No Lynch.

**Thor665**

I think he's more likely town than you and have indicated as such.
Why want to lynch him over, say, Drk_O?

**Drk_Oblitr8r**

I meant that you voting for me is very in character for you, and you were suspiciously quick to do so. As if you were only doing so in order to try to avoid suspicion

**Thor665**

So you're saying that to look town I should have done something other than what I might normally have done?

...
...
...naaaaah.

**BishopGore**

I think he's saying you're clever enough to play the game the same way whether you're town or scum and will usually kill him within a few days, so either way he's worried about you

I don't think any of us will get a read on Thor either way, whatever may happen.

Hi Mordo, glad you could join us, are you bandwagonning today?

**Rabtorian**

VOTE: Krellnus , as I was doing just fine voring him anyway. And he's voted me. Woopdeedoo.

**Drk_Oblitr8r**

Thor665 wrote:So you're saying that to look town I should have done something other than what I might normally have done?

...
...
...naaaaah.

I think I'm saying you're clever enough to play the game the same way whether you're town or scum and will usually kill me within a few days, so either way I'm worried about you.

I don't now if thats what I actually mean, but I think this is kinda close. I have never lived to the end of a game, but you usually kill me much earlier than I would have if you weren't playing.

Back responding to what you actually said, at the time you did it was. 9 mins 32 seconds previous Bishop said we should keep an eye on the people acting differently, so you did what you'd normally do.

If I'm not making any sense, I'm sorry, I have trouble with words sometimes.

**the_ferrett**

i'm busy most of this week. If I survive, grats.

**BishopGore**

And Ferrett is also careful to act completely in character

**RiTides**

A day and a half left... let's make some progress.

I am open to being convinced to change my vote- but less so than last game, since I was played like a puppet on strings

**the_ferrett**

Ferrett speaks and acts how he wants, thanks. For the record, Thorr plays everyone like a harp: Cue me stuck between voting out a guilty scum and a controlling guilty scum.

**RiTides**

Third person?

That's my problem- I can't tell if Thor is playing me or not, so I feel it's safest to have him gone...

**Mordoskul**

BishopGore wrote:Hi Mordo, glad you could join us, are you bandwagonning today?

Not gonna lie. I'm bandwagonning.

**BishopGore**

I am not happy with Thor's reasoning for pardoning Rabtorian. I'm not totally sure what it was that he meant and I want to know. A vote on Rabtorian seems less useful than actually pointing at Thor himself.

Vote: Thor665

Tell me why I shouldn't vote for you.

**VictorVonTzeentch**

Drk_Oblitr8r wrote:@BrotherStynier

It looks pink in bold, for some reason.

Well even normal it looks pink to me, but I've always been a little color blind regarding Violet and Pink.

Time left and vote count please.

**Thor665**

BishopGore wrote:I am not happy with Thor's reasoning for pardoning Rabtorian. I'm not totally sure what it was that he meant and I want to know. A vote on Rabtorian seems less useful than actually pointing at Thor himself.

I'm voting Rabtorian.
Thor says Rabtorian is town.
I don't believe him.
Vote Thor.

Look, if I *am* scum than you should recognize that as scum I happily bus my partners. Me defending someone means that either I think they are town, or I'm scum and I know they're town. Derpy-doo.
Voting people who get town reads on other players is not a good pro-town strategy.
You shouldn't vote me because I'll be a lot more amusing than most of these guys later in the game. Other than that you should vote me, but only if you actually think I'm scum.

**BishopGore**

You completely avoided the question and oversimplified the chain of events.

You vote Rabtorian.
I vote Rabtorian for similar reasons.
You unvote claiming a strong town read.
I ask what this read is based on.
I unvote Rabtorian out of lack of response from either party (it's Day 1, votes are flying all over) and then you say you don't want to say any more.
I apply pressure vote to you.

Voting for someone is a time honoured way of applying pressure. There's still plenty of time for me to move my vote elsewhere. Just don't see anywhere else for it to go, except No Lynch, and we both agree that is a poor use of a vote.

**Thor665**

So basically I'm not scummy to you and the extent of your pressure is you want me to justify a town read that you don't even feel is scum enough to keep pressuring?

Naaaah.